NIMBY Rails

NIMBY Rails

Train schedule complaining without reason
For some reason, my train schedule called Madrid - Barcelona complains without any reason. The schedule starts at 6:15 as an eastbound schedule and becomes westbound at 9:15, suggesting that it should become eastbound again at 12:15. The westbound train arrives in Madrid at 11:56:52, well in time for 12:15. But it does complain that "runs do not fit between previous and next order." When I change the time to something late, eg 20:15, and then press to set the departure as early as possible, it wants 16:37:06, even though it arrives at the first station before noon, why? It did work before, but not anymore.

Here's the link to a copy of the game:
https://share.nimbyrails.com/MFXUTZFacHbPLpTWF01wAA

Please don't care about the trains stuck at Madrid depot, they should be there for now.
Last edited by Ludvig07Bergqvist; 1 Mar @ 1:18am
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
adlet 2 Mar @ 9:09am 
It's pretty simple. Your line starts and ends in Madrid, but your first station is platform 1E and last station is platform 2S. If you look at your full line, you will see the distance to reach platform 1E (1st stop) is 1193 km, i.e. for a train to move from 2S to 1E it needs to go all the way back to Barcelona and then come back on the right platform. Note this is a known way how NIMBY timetable (unfortunately) works - even though both platforms are secondary to each other, and even though the train in reality won't move, but the timetable thinks it will move and adds this time. So when you are putting in the orders, the game thinks the train does not have time to move from 2S to 1E and simply skips those orders.

What you can do is use the same main platform for both times (either both 1E or both 2S). Alternatively you can create some way to work around the timetabling issue. For example if you just add a short dead-end track near Madrid this will create a way for NIMBY to think it can move the train quickly. For example like in a screenshot - this immediately resolves the issue. Note this short spur won't actually be used.

https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3437221841

It was just announced today that this timetabling issue should be resolved in 1.16 but there is no beta yet for that.
Originally posted by adlet:
It's pretty simple. Your line starts and ends in Madrid, but your first station is platform 1E and last station is platform 2S. If you look at your full line, you will see the distance to reach platform 1E (1st stop) is 1193 km, i.e. for a train to move from 2S to 1E it needs to go all the way back to Barcelona and then come back on the right platform. Note this is a known way how NIMBY timetable (unfortunately) works - even though both platforms are secondary to each other, and even though the train in reality won't move, but the timetable thinks it will move and adds this time. So when you are putting in the orders, the game thinks the train does not have time to move from 2S to 1E and simply skips those orders.

What you can do is use the same main platform for both times (either both 1E or both 2S). Alternatively you can create some way to work around the timetabling issue. For example if you just add a short dead-end track near Madrid this will create a way for NIMBY to think it can move the train quickly. For example like in a screenshot - this immediately resolves the issue. Note this short spur won't actually be used.

https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3437221841

It was just announced today that this timetabling issue should be resolved in 1.16 but there is no beta yet for that.

I get what you mean, but, I've set up the schedules in such a way that isn't a problem, which it hadn't been before. I would have picked the same platform in Madrid if I could, but the game doesn't allow that. Secondary platforms work though.

Also, when I loaded my save today, it worked without changes. So it seems it sometimes works and sometimes not for some reason.
Last edited by Ludvig07Bergqvist; 3 Mar @ 12:11pm
adlet 3 Mar @ 1:19pm 
Originally posted by Ludvig07Bergqvist:
I get what you mean, but, I've set up the schedules in such a way that isn't a problem, which it hadn't been before. I would have picked the same platform in Madrid if I could, but the game doesn't allow that. Secondary platforms work though.

Also, when I loaded my save today, it worked without changes. So it seems it sometimes works and sometimes not for some reason.

Yes you can definitely pick up the same platform any number of times. Press Alt and the yellow arrow should show. If it does not for any reason, switch to Advanced mode for stop selection, and you can pick up a specific place to stop anywhere on the platform.

Glad if your save is now working. My guess is something must have changed between the original design and when it stopped working, and may have changed again. As I noted above, it can be as simple as adding a short spur off the track that can make a difference. The game is not known for random behavior changes.
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
Per page: 1530 50