Hexcells

Hexcells

View Stats:
jorsh 24 Sep, 2014 @ 10:04pm
Can every puzzle be deduced?
Some puzzles, I have not been able to justify the position of some cells other than with trial and error, and this game is really only fun and challenging to me if I know for sure that every cell can be deduced. Some levels there are paths of deduction, but other levels (*cough cough* 5-2) I've had to just start guessing at one point or another, or there are rules that I'm missing, which is possible too.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 44 comments
BlaXpirit 24 Sep, 2014 @ 10:10pm 
Congrats, you're not very smart.
Especially since you didn't search for one of the billion copies of this topic.
jorsh 24 Sep, 2014 @ 10:13pm 
Congrats, you're an ass.
Especially since you didn't know you sign up for idiots like me when you use forums for games like Hexcell.
Nemonical-Yves 25 Sep, 2014 @ 4:09am 
Originally posted by BlaXpirit UA:
Congrats, you're not very smart.

There is clearly not enough information in the starting post to deduce this, so you are just guessing yourself. By your own logic that would make you "not very smart", but I don't know if that is really the case. I have to agree with this though:

Originally posted by theStandard:
Congrats, you're an ass.

To answer the initial question:
All levels in all of the three Hexcells games can be completely deduced, there is never a need to guess. Hexcells Infinite has a random level generator which generates levels in a way that guarantees them to be solvable without guessing.

However, support for user generated levels is coming for Infinite. The editor for these levels (made in part by the arrogant one) has no way of guaranteeing guess-free solving.
Berahlen 25 Sep, 2014 @ 6:56pm 
The reasoning can get a few more layers than you'd expect, but yes, all three games are 100% solvable without guessing.

I can't in completely good conscience vouch for the generator in Infinite (bugs are always possible), but I didn't come across an unsolvable one while getting the achievement.
antoniomad 15 Oct, 2014 @ 4:39am 
you're missing something...
Superbeef 28 Oct, 2014 @ 12:53pm 
Everything is solvable, and knowing why & how is one of the joys of playing. Post a screenshot of a level or situation you're having problem with, and someone can explain the solution in more detail.
Everune 28 Oct, 2014 @ 5:20pm 
Everything is solvable through pure logic, which makes it all the more embarassing to be stuck. I've got to admit I had to guess a few times myself, but oh well.
edderiofer 28 Nov, 2014 @ 10:35am 
As an experienced puzzle-solver (I have participated in a number of Logic Masters India tests, and help run a puzzle website), I can definitely attest that it's all solvable.
BigD 30 Nov, 2014 @ 10:53pm 
Every puzzle can be sovled ligically. Some of them take a really long time. Think about every possibility and post the screen shot in paint if you have to and decipher from there. They get annoying but it is worth it sovling them logically in the end. Good Luck!
There is definitely guesswork involved. I had to replay a few levels multiple times just based on memory because it was just like Minesweeper. It can be either here or there. Oh, you clicked the wrong one...screw you, start over.
Nemonical-Yves 4 Dec, 2014 @ 2:22pm 
Originally posted by Tired_David:
There is definitely guesswork involved.

Wrong. Many thought that, every single one of them missed something that would allow them to deduce the next step. I solved all of the designed puzzles in all three games and over 200 of the generated ones in Infinite without guessing even once.

Post as many screenshots as you like of situations where you "need to guess". You will be proven wrong in every one of them.
Last edited by Nemonical-Yves; 4 Dec, 2014 @ 2:22pm
Babies 4 Dec, 2014 @ 7:31pm 
Just backing up that all three games are solvable without guessing. I had to stare at some situations for thirty minutes to find the move I missed, but it's doable.

One way to mess yourself up is to prematurely mark a number "done" by right clicking it. I accidentally right clicked a blue number and my brain overlooked it every time I scanned the board for the next move.
Ha, I was stuck on 6-4 and then noticed something I hadn't before, and solved it by deduction only. I stand corrected.
Last edited by Wafflesaurus Supreme; 5 Dec, 2014 @ 9:13am
deezlicious 14 Dec, 2014 @ 6:40pm 
LOL, this thread.
MechaTails 28 Dec, 2014 @ 6:13pm 
Puzzle games bring out everyone's inner douche.

Some of them have seen impossible, but after I came back to it the next day, a new move opened up I didn't see before. Let your brainmeats rest a while if you're stuck, it helps.

Good to know they can all be deduced, however im not going to spend 30 minutes staring at a screen to make a move unless there are fleshy bits bouncing around. I'm going to enjoy the ones I can and leave the others. Having gotten each game in this series for a buck, I feel the timewasting-to-money ratio is balanced.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 44 comments
Per page: 1530 50