here, have my save file https://anonfiles.com/Bfday4rbb1/player_data_profile

Thanks for the profile, DiabloStorm. We'll take a look and get a fix in soon.

I have the same issue, and I have tried this 10 times already, same outcome, regardless of the option I pick during the Bounty Hunters encounter.

I have the same issue. Hope this can be fixed soon.

So... does anybody found any way of fixing the bug? Because I can't finish this damn quest in any of the multiple attempts I tried.

Alistair's Antiquities bug!
Всем привет! как насчёт исправления бага, которому скоро исполнится год?

Same here. I can only give it to Alistair, if it's unused, which doesn't give the token.

It's been a year with this bug still unpatched, I don't know if you guys intend to look at it, but I've tried to complete this token three times now with totally different paths hoping that at least one isn't bugged, but it's impossible through any means and the bugfix is needed.

I haven't personally followed this bug, and the HoF2 bug tracker was closed when the studio shut down, so there isn't an easy way for me to follow up on its status.

Given the current situation, I can't guarantee that there'll be an update with a fix for this, but I'll try to make some time to take a look and see if I can work out what's going on at some point over the next few weeks.

Originally posted by Cheeseness:

I haven't personally followed this bug, and the HoF2 bug tracker was closed when the studio shut down, so there isn't an easy way for me to follow up on its status.

Given the current situation, I can't guarantee that there'll be an update with a fix for this, but I'll try to make some time to take a look and see if I can work out what's going on at some point over the next few weeks.

Спасибо! Будем очень ждать!

Hey, I found a solution to this!

Since I stumbled across this while encountering the bug myself, I thought it might be helpful to share it here.

I first tried to do get the token (return the partialy used Item) while running the High Priestess scenario with a deck to help me do that thing, but I could not return the Item then.

Just now I was playing in an endless run using The Haunted (Upgraded Keturah) as my companion and I came across this exact card.
I went through all the dialog, collected the Item, told the Assassins I will not give them the Item (the option that immediately leads to fighting), I defeated them and used the Item 2 times while in combat.
After that I returned to Alistair and could return the Item with no problems.

So there is a way to get this done!

Originally posted by Cheeseness:

I haven't personally followed this bug, and the HoF2 bug tracker was closed when the studio shut down, so there isn't an easy way for me to follow up on its status.

Given the current situation, I can't guarantee that there'll be an update with a fix for this, but I'll try to make some time to take a look and see if I can work out what's going on at some point over the next few weeks.

I'd appreciate if you did. From my own testing it seems that:
a) You can return the item at full charges, which obviously fails the token, but is recognized.
b) If you hand out the item to the thieves, it's properly detected that you no longer can return it

There is a problem with charges calculation, and it seems that reloads of the game also affect it since I recall getting different results before and after a reload when testing different cases.

Originally posted by cptKadse:

Hey, I found a solution to this!

Since I stumbled across this while encountering the bug myself, I thought it might be helpful to share it here.

I first tried to do get the token (return the partialy used Item) while running the High Priestess scenario with a deck to help me do that thing, but I could not return the Item then.

Just now I was playing in an endless run using The Haunted (Upgraded Keturah) as my companion and I came across this exact card.
I went through all the dialog, collected the Item, told the Assassins I will not give them the Item (the option that immediately leads to fighting), I defeated them and used the Item 2 times while in combat.
After that I returned to Alistair and could return the Item with no problems.

So there is a way to get this done!

Проверено! работает! Наконец-то)

This bug is still existing two years after this thread was created.. Such a shame.

Originally posted by cptKadse:

Hey, I found a solution to this!

...

So there is a way to get this done!

I can confirm that there's a way around the bug. I think there's some issue with losing the "identity" of the item. I tried a few times, and, from my testing and this comment, I think you have to meet the Fame threshold when going into the encounter. Then, you can't load/reload or switch equipment. I used up two charges in two separate battles and was able to return it with three charges remaining.