I've looked everywhere, played all the mini games, got all the family members (and put them in the family tree, and exhausted all character dialogue I could find. I even got the piece from playing the slide puzzles. I'll check the end scene again, but I'm pretty sure I got the one everyone is mentioning. I'm at the end of my 4th or 5th play and the completionist in me is dying.

All I need is one more. It has to be hiding right under my nose somewhere...



EDIT: I found this in a discussion thread while searching for answers. It actually has all the locations. A major help! :

URL: https://www.steamah.com/later-alligator-family-badge-puzzle-pieces-guide/#Puzzle_Pieces

Skye says:
September 21, 2019 at 6:02 am

OKAY– unlike the list at the top, here’s ALL 48 PUZZLE PIECES. If you open up your “LG_Persistent.pts” file in your preferences for this game, there’s a whole bunch of variables listed. Many of them say, “PuzzleFound_#”– and so I’ll also list what each Puzzle Piece is listed as on there, for those interested. (What’s good about this approach is, if you search up PuzzleFound_#, and that isn’t found, then that means that’s what you missed.)

FUN DISTRICT – STREET, AT ANYTIME — after initial Slick Mickey puzzle & before 7pm
1) “BroDega” sign, right side of background (PuzzleFound_6)
2) Fifthwilliam the Fourth’s flower sign, when you drag the screen upward (PuzzleFound_7)
3) Hotel marquee (PuzzleFound_9)

FUN DISTRICT – STREET, AT 7PM
4) Exhaust dialogue options with Sleazarious (PuzzleFound_46)
5) Exhaust dialogue options with Fifthwilliam the Fourth, when you drag the screen upward (PuzzleFound_47)
6) Postal box (PuzzleFound_48)

FUN DISTRICT – ADELAIDE’S ARCADE
7) “Vampire Punter D” controls (PuzzleFound_2)
8) Second ski-ball machine (PuzzleFound_3)
9) Exhaust dialogue options with Artie, the alligator hiding, feet visible in upper-left hand corner of screen (PuzzleFound_4)
10) During Round 3 of Claw School with Sweet Geraldine, one of the prizes is a puzzle piece (PuzzleFound_1)
11) Beat “The Ol’ Pinny B.” with 5000 points or higher (PuzzleFound_5)

FUN DISTRICT – JOHN JOHNNY’S HOTEL, AFTER INITIAL VISIT
12) Leftmost chandelier (PuzzleFound_14)
13) Stack of coffee cups (PuzzleFound_15)

FUN DISTRICT – JOHN JOHNNY’S HOTEL, ANYTIME PAT’S NOT AROUND
14) Table where Pat usually sits (PuzzleFound_13)

FUN DISTRICT – JOHN JOHNNY’S HOTEL, AT 4PM
15) Talk to Nervous Derry (PuzzleFound_44)
16) Beat “Sole Searching” (PuzzleFound_43)

GOOD OL’ CLANCY’S TROLLEY
17) Transit route map (PuzzleFound_16)

ALLIGATOR MEMORIAL PARK
18) Top of the gazebo in the background, where Skids Valentino is (PuzzleFound_11)
19) Crying fountain statue (PuzzleFound_8)
20) Bridge, when you drag the screen to the right (PuzzleFound_10)
21) “Eat-Mergency!” sign, when you drag the screen to the right (PuzzleFound_42)
22) Exhaust dialogue with Theresa, the girl hiding on the bench when you drag the screen to the right. Go on transit, come back & exhaust dialogue again (PuzzleFound_12)

UNSAVORY PART OF TOWN – STREET
23) Very Adult Bar sign (PuzzleFound_20)
24) Drain (PuzzleFound_21)
25) Trash bags (PuzzleFound_22)

UNSAVORY PART OF TOWN – VERY ADULT BAR
26) Exit sign (PuzzleFound_23)
27) “Sippie Cups” sign (PuzzleFound_24)
28) Left bathroom door (PuzzleFound_25)
29) Bar stool next to Linda (PuzzleFound_40)

UNSAVORY PART OF TOWN – GIRLS GIRLS GIRLS
30) First time entering (PuzzleFound_17)
31) Clock (PuzzleFound_18)
32) Exhaust dialogue options with Sal (PuzzleFound_19)

DOWNTOWN – STREET
33) Exhaust dialogue options with Sleepypants. Go on transit, come back & exhaust dialogue options again (PuzzleFound_30)
34) Nana Rue’s neon eye sign (PuzzleFound_34)
35) Dumpster outside Nana Rue’s shop (PuzzleFound_35)
36) Left window on upper-right building (PuzzleFound_36)
37) Beat “Make My Wife, Please” legitimately (PuzzleFound_45)

DOWNTOWN – NANA RUE’S ANTIQUE SHOP
38) Safe (PuzzleFound_26)
39) Cash register (PuzzleFound_27)
40) Matryoshka dolls to the right (PuzzleFound_28)
41) Swords (PuzzleFound_29)

DOWNTOWN – BACKROOM IN NANA RUE’S SHOP
42) Lamp (PuzzleFound_31)
43) Mirror (PuzzleFound_32)
44) Typewriter (PuzzleFound_33)

9TH STREET – UNDERGROUND TUNNEL
45) Wheel on abandoned trolley (PuzzleFound_37)
46) Track barrier (PuzzleFound_38)

9TH STREET – BIG MAMA’S COFFIN ROOM
47) Pail to the left (PuzzleFound_39)
END OF GAME SCENE
48) Cake (PuzzleFound_41)