Need ‘Neutral’ Review Rating :: Suggestions / Ideas

Alle diskussioner > Steam-fora > Suggestions / Ideas > Trådoplysninger

PsychoPsyops 2. juli kl. 8:46

Need ‘Neutral’ Review Rating

Sometimes a game is just so average, you do not feel strongly one way or another about it overall and we need a neutral review rating to reflect this.

A work around is to not review it, however I would still like to say or point out things about a game for others, without the mandatory positive or negative review.

To only allow polarization is not a good idea, especially in times like these when the world in general is more polarized than it’s ever been.

Sidst redigeret af PsychoPsyops; 2. juli kl. 8:48

< >

Viser 1-15 af 99 kommentarer

rawWwRrr 2. juli kl. 8:48

Neutral = No

There's a big box to describe your opinions about the game. That's where you explain why you chose the recommendation that you did.

Duel Sundown 2. juli kl. 8:50

Oprindeligt skrevet af rawWwRrr:
Neutral = No

There's a big box to describe your opinions about the game. That's where you explain why you chose the recommendation that you did.

Tanoomba 2. juli kl. 8:51

The value of any individual review is derived entirely from the content of that review.
The value of the score aggregate derives from a large number of reviews. It honestly doesn't matter whether any individual review is "recommend" or "don't recommend".

rawWwRrr 2. juli kl. 8:53

I saw a screenshot on Reddit the other day of someone who wanted to give a 5-atar review, but because they hate the color yellow, and the stars were yellow, they marked it as 1-star.

GridNom XP 2. juli kl. 8:57

Knowing the audience, 80%+ games and products then will have 'neutral' reviews literally on every review.
Devs and players won't reach any conclusion afterwards.

Ben Lubar 2. juli kl. 10:57

"Should I play the game you played?"

If your answer is "I don't have an answer to that", then you just don't have an answer to that. If you still feel a need to tell people you don't have an answer to the question they came to get an answer to, start a curator group.

Mr. Smiles 2. juli kl. 11:36

Do you recommend the game?

"eh".

Not helpful.

[RO] Heliandra™ 2. juli kl. 12:34

No they don't need this. You either approve or disapprove. It would screw up the rating system lol.

Nx Machina 2. juli kl. 13:31

You are asked a question - Do you recommend this game to other players? and the answer is either yes or no and in the text box you explain why.

Neutral is a shrug of the shoulders and defaults to no.

Knee 2. juli kl. 13:36

Oprindeligt skrevet af PsychoPsyops:
To only allow polarization is not a good idea, especially in times like these when the world in general is more polarized than it’s ever been.

This is simply nonsense

#10

Tito Shivan 2. juli kl. 14:01

The thing is Steam "reviews" aren't really "reviews".
They're more like recommendations or endorsements (hence their binary yes/no nature). An actual review wouldn't necessarily have to be binary.

But Steam decided to call them "reviews" so now we have people doing a thing believing they're doing another.

#11

vova.khayan.84 4. juli kl. 1:47

Oprindeligt skrevet af rawWwRrr:
Neutral = No

There's a big box to describe your opinions about the game. That's where you explain why you chose the recommendation that you did.

Вот только в первую очередь человек смотрит на саму оценку.И даже если автор ругает игру,но остался ей более-менее доволен,то для читателя будет стоять лайк+критика=похвала.Кстати,поэтому и было изменено на "крайне положительные" и т.п.А "плохие" и "негативные" были убраны.
Именно поэтому я и читаю ТОЛЬКО негативные отзывы,т.к. более реальные отзывы.

Sidst redigeret af vova.khayan.84; 4. juli kl. 1:48

#12

Smiling Spectre 15. aug. kl. 0:37

I need "neutral" reviews for myself, and maybe for my friends. To know what I already played, but not came into any definite conclusion. Steam need polarized reviews for the forming the buying conclusion. Ok, I can understand it. Maybe worth to introduce two different review types then?

#13