All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details
Idolizing Karl Marx
Is equivalent to idolizing Hitler. Karl Marx was a racist, and his philosophies gave way to a political system responsible for the deaths of millions under Stalin and Mao.
Originally posted by kbiz:
Karl Marx was simply wrong. Communism will NEVER work because it doesn't incentivize productivity and innovation.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 252 comments
The author of this thread has indicated that this post answers the original topic.
kbiz 28 Jul @ 1:24pm 
Karl Marx was simply wrong. Communism will NEVER work because it doesn't incentivize productivity and innovation.
True communism is stateless and moneyless, that hasnt been achieved.
Idolising anyone is a bad idea. If you want to worship something, it has to be inherently greater than you.
Talby 28 Jul @ 1:39pm 
Marxism and social conflict go hand-in-hand. Then and now, just needed a little xtra socialness added...
Karl Marx was an idiot.
Originally posted by IcarianXT:
True communism is stateless and moneyless, that hasnt been achieved.

Utter and complete BS.

Communism relies on a single assumption: take away anything and everything that makes a human being human (ambition, desire, needs and wants etc etc) and the system will work.

Unless you can satisfy that assumption the system will not work.
And because that assumption is impossible to satisfy (unless you have millions of lobotomised semi-autonomous drones to serve as the workforce of your perfect, classless society), communism is just as equally impossible to achieve.

The practice of it however is another story.
And the fact that any single attempt to create a society inspired by Marx has brought nothing but misery and untold sufferings (and deaths) wherever it was tried should really teach us all a lesson
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VeWC9V2qH-8&ab_channel=hotdiggedydemon

isabelle just wanted to help the good people of the animal crossing village by introducing them to marxism.
malaria 28 Jul @ 2:38pm 
Originally posted by Immortalis:
Unless you can satisfy that assumption the system will not work.
And because that assumption is impossible to satisfy (unless you have millions of lobotomised semi-autonomous drones to serve as the workforce of your perfect, classless society), communism is just as equally impossible to achieve.

The practice of it however is another story.
And the fact that any single attempt to create a society inspired by Marx has brought nothing but misery and untold sufferings (and deaths) wherever it was tried should really teach us all a lesson
don't let tankies see this they'll talk your ears off about how it was actually capitalism who prevented communism from reaching it's true potential
Originally posted by Solidus Snake:
Is equivalent to idolizing Hitler. Karl Marx was a racist, and his philosophies gave way to a political system responsible for the deaths of millions under Stalin and Mao.

Marx wrote a thesis, Hitler subverted a whole nation and sent it spiraling into its downfall while murdering millions of people as a state policy, how exactly are they the same?
Originally posted by Immortalis:
Originally posted by IcarianXT:
True communism is stateless and moneyless, that hasnt been achieved.

Utter and complete BS.

Communism relies on a single assumption: take away anything and everything that makes a human being human (ambition, desire, needs and wants etc etc) and the system will work.
n

"From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs."

Communism doesn't forbid private property, it just forbids anyone owning the means of production. The factory is communal, the house is yours.
Houseman 28 Jul @ 2:43pm 
Originally posted by Fajita Jim:

"From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs."

Communism doesn't forbid private property, it just forbids anyone owning the means of production. The factory is communal, the house is yours.


What if I want to work from home?
Despiser 28 Jul @ 2:44pm 
I haven't heard that name for 45 years. We know why communism died, he didn't understand human nature.
Originally posted by Immortalis:
Originally posted by IcarianXT:
True communism is stateless and moneyless, that hasnt been achieved.

Utter and complete BS.

Communism relies on a single assumption: take away anything and everything that makes a human being human (ambition, desire, needs and wants etc etc) and the system will work.

Unless you can satisfy that assumption the system will not work.
And because that assumption is impossible to satisfy (unless you have millions of lobotomised semi-autonomous drones to serve as the workforce of your perfect, classless society), communism is just as equally impossible to achieve.

The practice of it however is another story.
And the fact that any single attempt to create a society inspired by Marx has brought nothing but misery and untold sufferings (and deaths) wherever it was tried should really teach us all a lesson

You havent read Marx, you just spout generic anti communist stuff.
kbiz 28 Jul @ 2:45pm 
Originally posted by Grendalcat:
Karl Marx was an idiot.

^five.
Houseman 28 Jul @ 2:45pm 
Originally posted by Despiser:
I haven't heard that name for 45 years. We know why communism died, he didn't understand human nature.

Many people still don't.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 252 comments
Per page: 1530 50

All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details