All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details
Why does Israel exist?
Well?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 45 comments
Well you see, back in 1945...
Becauase the West deemed it should
because yanks need a proxy to commit war crimes for them
Religious zealotry
because words and imaginary lines
Rothchild
Devious 23 hours ago 
It has little to do with religion. It was a secular project to begin with.

See, in the late 19th and early 20th century, nationalism was a fairly new idea in Europe. That's how the Jewish Question came to be : when we say, for example, "France for the French", does that include French Jews, who constitute a nation within a nation?

There were many answers to that, within and outside of the European Jewry. Assimilationists believed that a French Jew needed to be French first and foremost, even at the cost of his cultural heritage. Most early socialists believed in the abolition of old national divisions in favor of an international class struggle (which had generally positive implication for Jews). And of course, some ultranationalists decided that Jews should be expelled or exterminated.

Zionism (that is to say, Jewish nationalism that claims Mandatory Palestine as the Jewish homeland) was an alternative solution that was considered fringe at first, but gathered a lot of steam during and immediately after the Holocaust. Of course, it clashed with Arab nationalism, leading to 80 years of war and the situation we're at today.

Personally, I think that Israel should have been established in a mostly uninhabited area. But by 1948, there had already been mass Jewish immigration in Palestine specifically.
Last edited by Devious; 23 hours ago
Jews needed a country to protect them rights worldwide. And that is fair.




How it has been done, since the inception to today, on the other hand ... They should seriously had been setteld in some Brazilian forest. When you see how they developped the pack o'rocks and sand blasted by a scorching sun, one can only wonder what they could have done with a land with lot'o'trees, much much more water than in the Levant, and a nicer sun/temperatures.

They could had a Wakanda of marvels, by now, and that with no war, no displacments, no pain nor human suffering, no appartheid.


Every other major religion can do pilgrimages, and they do just that. Only them zionists wanted to inhabit the Temple itself.
Don't worry karma and god will be the ultimate judge.
Originally posted by 271k:
Well?
because they bought israel for 271k $$
271k 23 hours ago 
Originally posted by vkobe:
Originally posted by 271k:
Well?
because they bought israel for 271k $$

I thought they paid $6m
cause back in the day there were no space ships to send them directly into the sun
Last edited by Silverkite; 22 hours ago
Read history and you will find out.
The global cult needed a staging ground??
Originally posted by 271k:
Well?

What is your answer?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 45 comments
Per page: 1530 50

All Discussions > Steam Forums > Off Topic > Topic Details