After looking at your progress, honestly. Maybe its best if you include the missions on your list. Some maps have extremely different missions from each other and it does not help that you just classify a bunch of missions and then give a rating,

ngl I want to try to understand all the feedback here.

Butcher - Debatable. People seem to like lucid nightmares. Not sure why I don't though.
Heatrock - Sounds about right, its how big rock is designed if I'm being honest. The Expert's mission maker has this style for almost all his missions but I'm okay with it.
Kelly - Kelly easily has the worst missions in the entire tour. They're all repetitive and some are just outright bad.
Nightsky - Yeah... the mission maker isn't the best at balancing stuff (adv and int) while the Expert was a polished old mission
Shank - *which one theres 4-5 of them*
Skullcove - Eh I wouldn't say its great. Its good though.
Traumatic - Havn't really played it but personal opinion, I disliked terrorstorm just because of its super high cash.
Underworld - Yeah this might sound a bit bias since I made a mission on underworld but yeah. Subterrean and Unholy assault were rather spammy with commons, with unholy assault having some super long waves. Demonic Dominance might be spammy (specifically wave 2 and wave 5) as well but it had calm parts.

maps not listed there I have not played or I just don't want to give my opinion on it. (Lost Valley, Creepside, Whitecliff, Ledgermaine)

also u forgot
Null - 2 ok missions. 2 good missions.

Also what cultural bias is there to have in the first place.

Unholy Assault and Virtual Vortex had 7 days before it was demo'ed by Getty.
Call of Cthulu had 3 days by Getty too.
Horrorsome happenings N/A
Everything before that did not have a demo review.

Other Missions waiting for a demo review:
Spookee (31st Jul Accepted)... and that's about it.

"the law requires you to send this version to ur submission thread" (its the same one, apparently I left a random bracket in the above)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZjX-WzsM2TQFkaoBOn8xXnp3EpkfiBlR/view?usp=sharing

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1utEd1A5h3btfo1mhveE0ULyQU-vjd0m3/view?usp=sharing
Version 6.0

Wave 5:
Done the demoknights to 1.5
Also done the giant skull soldiers to 1 damage bonus against buildings

Wave 6:
Cut 2k hp of axe throw
cut 2k hp of spell caster

Decreased rage scale overall
Added rage scale to flame rage
Removed rage scale from spawns.

The first phase is the only phase with rage scale since its meant to be a "get your rage up" phase, it the most harmless but its also the most introductory. Rage phase was also meant to do that but because now the spawns gave rage it doesn't matter as much.

tag nav_prefer_main_back counter: 103
TextPrintTime 0 [$SIGSEGV]
Wave1: Put them on basically every single bot except the scouts on B and the axe pyros.
Wave 2: Put them onto basically every single bloody bot. AGAIN and also gave the pumpkin lords a "better icon"
Wave 3: PUT THEM ON EVERY SINGEL UCKING BOTH TOEAHTOEAHTAE
Wave 4: Put them on EVERYTHING.
Wave 5: Only giants get the tag.
ALSO WAVE 5: Regular meds turn into QUICK UBER MEDS. BECAUSE APPERENTLY REGULAR MEDS ON THIS MISSION IS TOO HARD.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nitd3qUdf2eqJPwym4w1f7zkcMYA5B79/view?usp=sharing

CHANGES V4.1 (Developer oversights and Cosmatic changes
https://drive.google.com/file/d/19e-SE6AWT_bTsLp40WhEpF-90eNREwSe/view?usp=sharing

EDIT: A SINGULAR PERIOD MISSING FROM THE TEXT (4.2)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UbS9EOV6ePcqvfXuG3IhrNnnVpLfIzTm/view?usp=sharing

Eyelander and Headtaker now have flying bits instead of burning player particles

Wave 3 now has the proper rapidfire giant icon (wave 1 technically has a giant demoman that fires slghtly faster and reload slightly faster)

Wave 4 and 5's skull soldiers now have flying bits rocket launchers

Wave 6's final phase is fixed (Giant demoknights are suppose to also die along with the boss)
Axe throw phase also now has flying bits for the axe

Singular wave buff:
Wave 4's medics for subwave A and B now have higher uber thresholds so better teams literally can't snap them into pieces as easily and quick ubers meds in subwave 1 are slightly longer. (Might as well make it harder for everyone than just randoms)

This is to help with even more consistnecy of the mission. Wave 4 is one of more easier waves by a long shot. Subwave 1 and 2 being scraped extremely easily. and subwave 3 pushing a little bit. This is mostly due to the high amounts of cash leading to the near instant deaths of all the medics before they are able to pop and make an impact.

Hopefully the final change
https://drive.google.com/file/d/164riUTL1MPNRnmH2qz3qkCxbY8BOkcp6/view?usp=sharing

Wave 2
Subwave C: Changes heavy spawns from 15 - 18 (just to help consistency

Wave 3
Subwave A: Unsquaded the pyros and scouts.
Subwave C: Tied the last subwave to a waitforallspawned instead of a waitforall dead

Wave 4
Subwave C: Since crits are hard coded Hell-met gave an alternative to make them minicrit instead of crit.

Wave 5
Subwave A: buffed first tank to 25k

Wave 6
If I remembered correctly...
I nerfed the health of the bison soldiers and the pyros for flame storm
Nerfed health of Spell caster and flame storm
Nerfed movement speed on Axethrow
Nerfed Monoculas on Spellcaster.

Overall:
Fixed Grammar lol.
From what I saw, basically every wave pushed to similar lengths except for wave 4. However wave 4 seems to be more harder towards randoms (mostly cos medics) and it also gets stomped hard by shield.

CHANGES V3.2
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1vkZ4uz_i6Ek6Zu9u1KXb0bmlfSMtIN4P/view?usp=sharing

Wave 1:
Gave the giant demoman reload...

Wave 2:
Fixed the broken sun stick spawns (or they originally weren't broken)

Yes, I made an thing just for 1 small change to help with consistency.

CHANGES V3.1
https://drive.google.com/file/d/12I6hwu4LW8R6eIoDYjV4-xzansu-y40X/view?usp=sharing
This is probably the final time I'll change it cos every change I've made has been to make difficulty more consistent or at least stand out too much out of difficulty. So I might as well include comments about each change.

Tank Changed from 15k - 14k

This is infact the only wave to consistently push to hatch because of the tank. Teams without enough tank DPS will definitely struggle with this slightly me, so a small nerf to it will be preferred. Even with pyros, the tank will always be enter the final area before being destroyed.

I was tempted to make it so that the demoman and pyro squads come in the same spawnbot rather than alternate between side and main but all it really does is allow them to be spawn camped rather than fix the demoman being a bigger threat.

Removed Damage bonus on heater heavy (1.2 to 1)
Made it so that the sunstick scouts spawn quickly for the first 10 seconds and weaken afterward.

Upon closer inspection, this subwave is notorious for crushing teams due to how the support scouts end up distracting teams from being able to kill the giant heavies.

Added a building Damage bonus (5) for the heavy
Seriously that thing does NOTHING to sentries, let alone WRANGLED SENTRIES. The heavies at the start do help out with trying to kill it though.

Reworked Meteor phase to shoot 1 meteor every 5 seconds, 2 times then to slam 3 meteors right after each other for FPS purposes.

Overall Mission in my opinion
After doing a bunch of tests, a team with 4 randoms and 2 descent players should be able to fair against it decently. A team with 6 random will definitely struggle a lot more but most difficult parts of the mission can be solved by milk + heavy, shield, revives or just more firepower. Engie plays a really good but not necessary role here.