Many of the endings depend on whether or not you befriend Morgan and Juliet. If you want the specific choices spoiled, here's the place to do it.

After he asks who Black is:
Talk with him: -5
Refuse to talk: +10

Natives are about to attack the pirates:
Start screaming: +10
Try to sleep: -5

Morgan considers killing Robert:
Try to grab his sword: +10
Beg him to spare Robert: -5

When Exploring the Ship, choose: Approach Morgan:
Flirt with him: -5
Leave him: +10



When Juliet asks Heileen why she's crying:
Tell the truth: +10
Tell a lie: -5

Natives are about to attack the pirates:
Start screaming: +10
Try to sleep: -5

When Exploring the Ship, choose: Approach Juliet:
Stay here: +10
Go away: -5

When Ebele pushes Heileen so she falls at Juliet's feet:
Talk to her: +10
Leave her alone: -5

Ending Type: Island

After you get the map you'll have to make a decision of what to do from there. Choose "I don't want to explore the island" and stand by your choice.

Ending Type: Pirate

Basically for this you want to make sure you get the quests "Marcus the Pirate" and "A Pirate's Trust" and solve both of them. Build a good relationship with Morgan and Juliet.

In-depth version:

• During the second round of Charity, choose: Look for Marcus.
  
• Solve "A Pirate's Trust" by warning the pirates about the natives.
  
• Solve "Marcus the Pirate" by talking to Morgan the night you've been brought onto the ship.
  
• Befriend both Juliet and Morgan.

Ending Type: Pirate

Be a virtuous person overall, and don't get the diamond. Earn the pirate's trust but don't befriend Juliet and Marcus.

In-Depth Version:

• More than 50% of the dreams ended with virtues.
  
• In the third round of Charity/Greed, choose: Do Nothing.
  
• Warn the pirates about the natives.
  
• Do NOT befriend Juliet and Marcus.

Ending Type: Pirate

Get the diamond. Don't earn the pirate's trust.

In-Depth Version:

• In the third round for Charity/Greed, choose: Catch Otto's attention.
  
• When the natives show up after the pirates and you're prompted to respond, choose: Try to sleep.

Ending Type: Pirate

At the end when you’re in the ship with Juliet, choose ‘Check the desk’.

If you don't make it to this part for whatever reason, then try warning the pirates about the natives.

Ending Type: Island

Don't get the mirror. In the third round of Envy/Kindness, choose: ‘Why she always flirt with everyone’.

Ending Type: Island

Have a good relationship with both Ebele and Robert. Get the quests "Ebele's Feelings" and "Robert's Feelings".

Hints:
Completeing either quest independently means you won't get the ending. So if you only see Ebele or Robert you didn't get it.
Likely requires a mix of sin and virtue cards. I couldn't get it with just virtues, and going only with sinful choices usually results in lower affection or no change at all.


I had a very difficult time getting this ending because you have to balance the relationship between Robert and Ebele very carefully, so instead of an in-depth guide, I'm doing a flat out walkthrough for anyone who was tired of it like I was.

Walkthrough:
Part One:

• Sure
  
• Yes
  
• Warn her about the flower --> Tell Ebele your feelings
  
• Tell sister Anna to stop
  
• I want to stay here --> Yes I want to explore it
  
• We could go around the jungle through here?
  
• Robert is fishing
  
• Ebele is gathering fruits
  
• Go here to dream again
  
• Pride/Humility --> No --> Ask for Ebele's help
  
• Lust/Chastity --> Tell Lora to send John away --> Suck the venom
  
• Gluttony/Temperance --> Share the food and drink with them --> Yes...
  
• Greed/Charity --> Give the bag to the beggars --> Show it to Ebele
  
• Sloth/Diligence --> Get back to work
  
• I'm ready to move forward to next step!

Part Two:

• Yes, it seems like a good plan
  
• Robert is trying to build a rope
  
• Ebele is preparing food
  
• SAVE - There's an event for both "I should try fishing here..." (Robert) and "I want to examine the river again..." (Ebele) but triggering them is random. You have a limited number of chances before the option disappears. So try for one. If you get it save again and get the other one. If not reload until you get it.
  
• Gluttony/Temperance --> Insist that Marie to eat too --> I believe Robert's theory
  
• Greed/Charity --> Look for Marcus --> Show the shoes to Robert
  
• Sloth/Diligence --> Help Marco --> Try the rope yourself
  
• Warth/Patience --> Wait and see what happens --> Give it to Robert
  
• Envy/Kindness --> Ask her to stay here --> Let Ebele cure you
  
• Pride/Humility --> It was a horrible journey --> Ask Robert
  
• Lust/Chastity --> No --> Tell you didn't want to embarass Robert

Part Three:
[/list]

• Robert is fishing and scouting
  
• Ebele is preparing food
  
• SAVE - Again, get the events for both "This small jungle here looks interesting" and "I could search this beach here".
  
• Go here to dream again
  
• Lust/Chastity --> Examine the shawl --> Ask her about Robert
  
• Gluttony/Temperance --> Insist that Marie come eat with you --> Eat it!
  
• Greed/Charity --> Do Nothing --> Tell a lie
  
• Sloth/Diligence --> Accuse Lora --> Ask Ebele
  
• Warth/Patience --> Believe him
  
• Envy/Kindness --> Why she never got married --> Scold Ebele
  
• Pride/Humility --> Adam is wrong --> Give it to Robert

Ending Type: Pirate

You lied to the pirates about Robert and Ebele kidnapping you, and you didn't warn them about the natives.

Ending Type: Island

Fail to get the rope to pass the river. In the second round of Lust/Chastity, choose: Yes.

Ending Type: Pirate

Don't get the quest "Marcus the Pirate" and don't get the diamond. Earn the pirate's trust and be on good terms with Morgan and Juliet.

In-Depth Version:

• In the second round of Greed/Charity, choose: Inform Sister Anna.
  
• Warn the pirates about the natives.
  
• Befriend Morgan and Juliet.

Ending Type: Pirate

Get the diamond. Earn the pirate's trust but don't befriend Julet and Morgan.

In-Depth Version:

• In the third round for Charity/Greed, choose: Catch Otto's attention.
  
• Warn the pirates about the natives.
  
• Do not befriend Juliet and Morgan.

Ending Type: Island

In the first round of Sloth/Diligence, choose: Start Crying

Ending Type: Pirate

You don't have the diamond, and you didn't earn the pirate's trust.

In-Depth Guide:

• In the third round of Greed/Charity, choose: Do Nothing.
  
• Do not warn the pirates about the natives.

Ending Type: Pirate

Be sinful. Don't get the diamond. Earn the pirate's trust, but don't befriend Juliet and Morgan.

In-Depth Version:

• More than 50% of the dreams ended with sins.
  
• In the third round of Greed/Charity, choose: Do Nothing.
  
• Warn the pirates about the natives.
  
• Do not befriend Morgan and Juliet.

Ending Type: Island

Get the almanac. In the second round of Sloth/Diligence, choose ‘Refuse to Help’.