165 ratings
Naming & Shaming: Explained
By Mr. G
Understanding Naming & Shaming, and why you should avoid it.
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
What is Naming & Shaming?
Naming & Shaming, or abbreviated as "N&S" is the term of when you post someone's profile URL / ID on a forum or any public board / area. Not many people know that Naming & Shaming is a violation to Steam's rules (or they do know it and ignore it). Most of the time, people will post the Steam ID of someone and request the readers to mass report the said profile for obvious reasons - cheating.There is of course other reasons that may trigger people to do it; however we'll be discussing the common one, cheating.
Why is Naming & Shaming against Steam Rules?
1. Because when a large amount of users mass report a possible cheater (we'll call him Bob), it creates a huge clutter for Support (or spam if you will). Since Support reviews each report case by case, they're having to take more time to go through all of the repetitive reports on Bob. There for, Support is dramatically slowed down and the rate of bans have been reduced. Not only that, other cheaters in the community are running around longer cause Support was bogged down due to that mass report.


2. Naming & Shaming doesn't belong anywhere in the forums / public area. That is another reason why the report system was created, so it would stay out of the forums.

3. Posting a Steam URL of someone's profile proves nothing. On the internet, words mean literately nothing.

4. You may think, what if I have video proof that someone is actually cheating. Then it must be okay for me to Name & Shame - NO! This ties into rule 2. Cheater or not, it does not belong in the forums.


5. In-game reports were created for a reason. Naming & Shaming is not taking advantage of that tool.

6. Valve doesn't determine a person's fate off of a large amount of reports. Once a user is flagged, they'll then start investigating with other data that doesn't involve player's reports.

7.
"What if I post my YouTube video of the possible cheater with the Steam URL / ID in the video description box and not in the thread, is it Naming & Shaming?".

Yes, it is still Naming & Shaming. You aren't allowed to post a YouTube of the person with their account URL / ID anywhere on Steam. A lot of people think they can do what they want, cause it's their video. However, rules and moderation say other wise.

8. Time is usually wasted when a user creates a Name & Shame topic. Users will tell other users why Naming & Shaming is a rule, and many will ignore it. Then that usually leads to a former Moderator having to interfere and take action as he/she see fit.

9. While sometimes when you Name & Shame someone, you probably are right that the person is cheating. However, there are many occasions where the suspected cheater is actually a legit player. Then Valve is having to (again) waste time cleaning of reports on legit players due to the process of N&S.

I Refuse to Follow Naming & Shaming
Like most, you're probably thinking I'm not going to follow this rule. Well, you can't just pick and choose what rules to follow. It's rather all or none. So you may want to keep reading.

1. You accepted the forum rules upon creating your account and making your first post on the forums. So you're bound to that agreement when you use the forums or anyplace on Steam.

2. You may also be wondering where there is any proof or facts to back this rule up. There is plenty around the community. Read the below guide and links.

First Statement

Second Statement

Third Statement

Fourth Statement

Fifth Statement

Sixth Statement

https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=143962136
Conclusion
There really isn't anything that you can say to make the previous statements incorrect. Naming & Shaming is a rule, and it's a rule we all must follow if we are to use the forums. N&S also causes many other damages to the system; allowing other cheaters to get away longer.

There are three possible ways to report a suspected cheater that doesn't involve Naming & Shaming.

  • Report in-game
  • Report via Steam profile
  • Report to the developer's social media network (if they have it)


When using the forum, I hope that you'll obey Naming & Shaming and other forum rules. It is for your own good that you follow the rules. It keeps the community safe and gives it structure.

Leave questions / concerns in the comment section below. Thanks!

- Captain Price
72 Comments
Jon the VGNerd 23 Dec, 2023 @ 5:21pm 
It's quite funny how naming and shaming is bad, but when it comes to trolls that deliberately cause trouble that's anything but naming and shaming, they get a 5-star treatment instead of actually suspending their Steam accounts for good. Valve moderators have clearly gone ass backwards. :steamfacepalm:
Aya 26 Nov, 2023 @ 7:25am 
Soulcalibur VI community hub is being bombarded by a scammer that's posting the same malicious link over and over again as of 2023-11-26.

https://i.imgur.com/tSxJXWY.png
AquaeAtrae 4 Aug, 2023 @ 7:24pm 
Announced August 2nd, 2023: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II :)
RICOCHET has entered the chat 🛡️

Starting in Season 05, the kill feed will notify lobbies when #TeamRICOCHET and it's systems have removed a problem player from the game.
NNNMAN ⁧⁧🔊*🎮🏆⏫ 27 Jul, 2023 @ 1:25pm 
Also Banned / Blocked People cant write and defend themselves if a horde of Users jumps on the Hate Train while they do that the banned users can only look on how they get Slandered.. I would be more Ok if Innocent and Guilty people together get banned for now most Innocent people who are alone get the Short Stick..
NNNMAN ⁧⁧🔊*🎮🏆⏫ 27 Jul, 2023 @ 1:23pm 
Name And Shame could Lead Someone innocent to lose out because EVIL always tries to be stronger while good doesn't. In the End Steam or Any Game Moderator would Ban the Alone User if 8 Or more People come together and insult that User In the End Alone people / A small Group gets Punished because of the Will of the Toxic and Hate Bringing People..
AquaeAtrae 26 Jul, 2023 @ 7:18pm 
(1/2) Sorry, after all these years I still disagree with this ...in principle. I think it is a great thing that Steam publicly shows ban status on our profiles. And I support the nuanced approach the PUBG: BATTLEGROUNDS Anti-Cheat Team recently announced (official blog post below). sharing their "list of permanently banned accounts".

https://steamhost.cn/news/app/578080/view/3655284673663101096?l=english

That being said, I recognize how futile and unproductive it is to do this in these forums, at least those where devs never engage. More and more, the shame that may discourage some cheaters should really be presented publicly by the anti-cheat teams like Valve Anti-cheat and PUBG's have.

When the community grows so frustrated with a particular cheater that they name and shame them in the forums, their outcry it's so much about that one cheater as it is the underfunded, understaffed, or non-existent anti-cheat controls that they expected with that game they...
AquaeAtrae 26 Jul, 2023 @ 7:18pm 
(2/2) otherwise love so much. Few appreciate how very difficult accurate anti-cheat detection truly is.

Even for dev presented naming and shaming to be effective, social profile identities need permanence so a gamer's reputation grows to actually matter to them. And their reputation should be based on duration and in-game engagement (not how many tokens they purchase). Players (especially on PC) desperately need to know their reports are being heard and the something, literally anything, is being done about them. And we all need to see that consequences (bans) are regularly applied, even occasionally for old games.

We do see token efforts and hopeful messages from the devs, but cheating remains the core problem in online gaming. Sadly, low-level efforts like True Play always seems to end before they get off the ground. Perhaps AI will revolutionize anti-cheat. But realistically, the opposite seems more likely given the amount of funding the cheat industry controls.
Jon the VGNerd 24 Jul, 2023 @ 2:35am 
@Aya: Valve Moderators are incredibly slow and inconsistent in handling reports. And Steam Support is virtually useless.
Aya 23 Jul, 2023 @ 11:11am 
Actually, a serious question: How else are you supposed to deal with someone who has been spamming the same malicious link over and over again for over a month? By that point, he should already be reported by multiple users. If them getting reported was enough, they'd be banned by now, but they're still spamming the same malicious link over and over again. Would it be morally correct to name and shame despite community guidelines?
Aya 5 May, 2023 @ 2:30pm 
I wouldn't partake in naming and shaming myself, though I will admit that some games don't exactly have the best anti-cheat or in-game reporting systems. What happens then when your only option is to risk eating a ban yourself?