Hello LM. I was wondering if you had considered doing a balanced version?
+ You get excellent Food, balanced I.D.S. with +5 approval, or, good Sci or Ind and no approval for 15 points
+ You get either Sci or Ind with good food, or, overall balance with a -5 approval for 10 points.
+ Arid and Snow give you less Food and -10 approval for 5 points.
- MEDI and TUNDRA give 6 food and -5 approval with only 2 points less for Ind/Sci. The Food will give you pop faster which give more FIDS and the disapproval differences are also going to help improve your FIDS as well.
-- Desert and Arctic are similar to Snow and Arid but have less food by one and more dust by two. Making them worth a 5 (or if possible 3 point start)
--- Toxic is more Dust but less F.I.S. with -20 approval should be 0 or +5 points start; because, no matter how much you want to buy your way to a good start, money can't buy you F.I.S. early game and a -20 disapproval is going to make you have even less FIDS.

so I guess i am asking if you and make the new planets 5 points and the toxic a 0 point
Link about approval effect on FIDS. https://endless-space-2.fandom.com/wiki/Approval