I tested it and at the time of writing this the mod seems to be broken: with the mod on, phalanx unit have the "Pike Phalanx" ability button seemingly on by default and clicking it has no effect; when enemies get close, the unit seems to lower the pikes and assume formation, but upon contact the enemy will immediately push through the pikes and engage in melee range, deforming the pikemen's line almost immediately. When I tested without the mod, the ability button worked normally and the enemy charge was stopped by the pikes.

For those with the sword draw issues -> Load Order ! when i load this mod BEFORE the DEI core mod it works as intended. Formations don't draw sword on contact but rather have this pike/spear stab animation. it also seems to be effective. I also load the Hoplite Phalanx/Shieldwall before the core DEI mod.

Hello!
I have an issue where the pike units don´t go into a formation, and if attacked, they use swords.
I moved the mod above DEI, still persists.
May be buged, not sure, just thought I would write it here.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure it is bugged. My pikes immediately switch to swords when the enemy charges them. I can sometimes reform them and get them to use pikes again, but it is basically random.

I dont think this mod works anymore. My Pikes are completely useless. they get into really close quarters combat and die to basic inf.

Did I understand correctly that this mod replaces the animation of the pike with the animation of the spear, or does it not work correctly for me?

genuinely impressed with this mod! The pikes actually seem realistic in combat. Can't speak for the buffs/nerfs, but the behavior feels so much better

because of this mod I can't make my units use their pikes. fix it pls.

I have no issues using this mod, pikemen use pikes in formation attack. Those having trouble, maybe try different load order?

Bug still persists as of this year - I believe the mod remains broken :(

I am also seeing pikemen only use swords in my games as well. Whenever I try to use pikes they just stay up.

Hey Kam, I also get the Bug that they use Swords instead of Pikes. Any Fix?=)

is this updated for the latest patch? 1.3.1?

I think is this bugged, cuz pike phalanx just dont use pikes ! they only use sword.

can I use it with Hoplite Phalanx/Shieldwall submod ? im not sure is it because i use both, but some falangs dont even using their spears anymore

Awesome. Thanks so much kam.

thank you thank you Thank You

Updated for DeI 1.3

Will this mod be integrated into future Dei updates？

UPDATE UPDATE UPDATE!!! 2022!!!

is this update?

Does this mod make the phalanx stronger or weaker in general?

update

Hello Kam ! I am a great fan of your mod that give much power to the macedonian phalanx which has become weaker against the traditional hoplites in the new version of DEI ...
I would like to know if you can make the same version of your mod with the same stats but with keeping the historical behaviour of the phalangites in combat, like in the vanilla ?
Thank you !

Can I use for DEI 1.2.8 + New_GC_startpos ?

Hey, sorry to bother you but I had some issues:
I had a weird bug with the Suebi today. The Markamannoz Speutagardaz (Markamannoz Pikemen) unit I had placed suddenly turned 90 degrees during an engagement.
Hoplites my friend was using did not turn.

I am using both your Hoplite and Phalanx mod. They are loaded before Die though not directly (Settler and Hardcore mod is inbetween).
There is no mod that should affect battle gameplay apart from your and Die.

My bad, this mod works fine. I didn't realize about this load order. Thanks, good mod

Pls fix, this seems like an amazing mod that'll go perfect for all the pike factions

Because you have wrong load order, load mod above DeI.

wtf with this mod my phalanx don't use pikes at all they fight with swords

Should this mod ever be fixed, is it right that it will make all pike units always stay in pike formation? Thats all I really want, I hate seeing them run across the god damned map

they just go straight to swords no matter what

DeI parts 1, 2 and loaded in that order, and this mod loaded in 4th place. Seleucid sarissas run upto my frontline and engage with swords. Not sure how anybody is getting a different result as this must be the minimum required modcount. Custom battle in some grassland Rome vs Seleucids

Mod updated for 1.2.7!

hey Kam, cam u pls update both phalanx and pile subs? really love it!

Well i made an experiment (This review is with all due respect and i mean no offense to creator) i tested alexander the great custom battle on Macedonia

Me with 812 troops 1 phalanx 2 spear vs 1150 enemy troops, general spear, archer, slinger, and 2 swordys.

In my experiment with your mod i did horrible results with my general dying and losing 461 troops barely wining, due to the lack of proper pike properties as standing ground.
Without your mod i lost 350 troops, and my gen wasnt killed and i tried the same tactics and paths.

So i ran multiple experiments like this and i can say as conclussion that your mod is not bad, and animations are cool, but even with the buffs to proyectiles and stuff they are not even close to vanilla if properly managed, so i would suggest to buff even more this stats and try this experiments on your own.

Thanks for reading

also this mod is great even if it makes the animation a lil wacky it brings pikes to a gameplay point that they should've always been at

would it be possible to make them switch to swords when u turn off formation attack

They pull out the sword when dying, though - but in combat use the pike. Not really an issue for me...

! thanks..so much better, they do finally some proper stabbing and keep the formation.
(no animation issue on my end with both phalanx submods...)

The same problem. It switchs to swords in combat

Have this issue as well. The Pikemen always switch to swords in combat.

some pike units switch to swords

lovely thx a bunch

Mod updated for 1.2.6.

Just a heads up, this is not yet compatible with latest 1.2.6 release. I will work on it.

So current state : yes, the one hand animation bug is still here. and 2, it makes pikes almost completely useless, they dont get kills from frontal attacks like vanilla DEI. This still needs work ;D

hello kam2150. Is the non beta launcher ok with your submod ? Dresden talk about beta launcher candidate (1 year ago..) to avoid issues with submods

Then please read description why it was done like that. It was not supposed to make it look more accurate but to bypass base game bugs.