Yeah, why doesnt this have the classic menu music when the linked alternate does?

Please, please, PLEASE add the old title screen music. It's literally the only thing wrong with this mod.

I really love this mod but the title screen not playing the right song is a kinda big downside to me. Can we find a way to fix it? I tried Zukol's track 13 fix but it fixed nothing. If the mod creator are too busy to maintain this maybe we can get the mod on github and I can help you out contributing.

Danny B really is a musical genious.

Hi folks, I was able to get the title music to work correctly, here's a pastebin of the fixed music.xml file that you can paste over the old one; Go to your steam/steamapps/workshop/contents path and find the numbered file that corresponds to Isaac, open it and then find which numbered file is this mod. Then, open it's resource folder to find the music.xml file.
Example path: C:\Program Files (x86)\Steam\steamapps\workshop\content\250900\842545730\resources

https://pastebin.com/NM9CQVyD

A summary if the pastebin is inaccessible: Track id 63, name 'Title Screen (Repentance)' is the name that corresponds to the actual title song path if you are on Repentance, however it is assigned to the regular repentance title music which is why you hear it. To fix, remove and replace <track id="63".....0.01" /> with:

<track id="63" name="Title Screen (Repentance)" intro="Title Screen Intro.ogg" path="Title Screen.ogg" loop="true" />

any luck with (2) yet?

If anyone's wondering, achievments are enabled, i checked

@Maleverus pls use the antibirth tracks

@Maleverus Dang, what a bummer QWQ Hopefully they reply back soon!

@Salakirby I wish I did. It's not actually a bug with *this* mod, but any mod that tries to supply new music will experience it. Simply replacing the music at all causes it. I have reported it to the Ridiculon and the programmer who maintains the modding system, but no response yet.

I noticed a bug in this mod. When resetting runs using R, if music is currently playing on Basement ends up switching to Burning Basement and vise versa, the music completely cuts out for that floor. Do you know of any way to fix this?

I also like ridiculon's music. I'd like the mod to have a 50/50 chance to play dannyB or ridiculon

Hmmm do u mod include main menu theme from flash? Cause i still hear RP main menu theme

Quiet like this mod, would it be possible for you to replace the current angel room theme with The Wages of Faith? Is an unused track that I assume for wraith of the lamb was suppose to be the angel room theme but never got used, I think it would be a nice edition if possible.

Hi! I was wandering, is it possible to make a classic music mod that randomly chooses to play the original music or classic music? Like in Spelunky, where there are rare alternate versions of the each track.

Achievments enabled with this mod?

You are doing God's work, my friend

Thank you all for the bug reports, I really appreciate them. I am working on an update to address them all so please keep any coming. It's a big update though taking a lot of time on top of 2 jobs and a family xD

is the main menu music supposed to be the repentance track and not the classic? it is still the repentance one

The main menu music seems to be normal music and not the classic.

Hey @Maleverus, awesome job on this mod, I really appreciate your dedication to put in the highest quality files you find. I have a request that may or may not be complex to implement.

Would it be possibile to have ALL renditions of a stage? What I mean is having the classic, the rebirth/ab+/repentenace and antibirth music in one single mod. The mod would then choose randomly between for example Rebirth or Classic music for basement I, and so on if there are multiple versions.

@maleverus usually wav is the best quality with minimal compression if any

I mean, I do have the WAVs from Danny's Bandcamp. So I can access the FLACs easily if I need to.

@SoupCanMafia and all. Now that Isaac is "done", I'm planning on doing a hopefully final (unless bugs) update to this Mod. This Mod uses DannyB's music extracted from the Flash file. Not promising a timeline here, but I want to redo everything based on the highest quality source I can find with new max quality OGG conversions. I'll remake loops and intros from higher quality sources as necessary, but only if I can 100% match timings (if I can't match timing will stick with original extracts).

So here's the question: What's the best available source for every track. Best I'm finding is the FLACs on Dannys bandcamp. So if anyone knows if there is better quality than this, or more specifically higher quality versions of anything missing on Danny's bandcamp, speak now or forever hold your peace.

@OedonWrithe I already have! Thats the way I wanted it. But a popular vote on this mod wanted to keep Ridiculon for new stuff. So I did this version the way the plurality of users wanted,and made a new version that works like your saying I think you'll really like: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2489813335

@SoupCanMafia Thank you VERY much. Will try and get to it soon, maybe this weekend.

Do you intend to mix this with Mudeth's music? As in, normal floors = DannyB, Antibirth floors = Mudeth? That would be awesome.

TL:DR
Serenity should replace Super Secret Room
And The Binding of Isaac should replace Genesis or Genesis II

https://youtu.be/nXaqwUVLOwA Just as proof, this is their music for the Super Secret Room, entitled "Super Secret Room". Funny, you could now say nowadays the Ultra Secret Rooms are the true Top Secret Rooms lol

@Maleverus The OG Menu Theme is simply titled "The Binding of Isaac", interesting to note is that it actually starts 19 seconds ahead of the track start, like a buffer point for loop logic if we wanna be accurate to Flash Isaac. And you're right on the mark with Serenity being the Top Secret Room theme.

@SoupCanMafia Thanks man. Yes If I'm missing music from DannyB's original I intend to correct that. After 10 years and countless Isaac versions, I'm not surprised but hate the fact that I may have missed anything. Can you help me be more specific on what I'm missing and where it goes? Is the top secret music the track serenity? and which track is the OG menu theme because I already have a DannyB menu theme. Its all blurring together. Just need to identify the exact tracks missing, where to put them, and I will update ASAP. thanks!

I got a question, Male. Will the OG Menu theme come back? As well, you could put in the Top Secret Room music since (IIRC) that's back in now. Or is that the Full-Replace music?

@DarkJuda @Nico @Pakoito And anyone else interested!
The version of this Mod with Antibirth tracks is done and available here: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2489813335
This is the one I will be using. I would have done that to this version, but the plurality of people wanted to keep Repentance tracks, thus the versions.

@slood, I've already committed to making at least 4 variations of this mod to make everyone happy. I like doing it, but I can't make one offs for everyone. I can tell you its easy to do! In the mods folder in Isaac go to this mod, and in music.xml find track 27. Replace the whole line with this original and the original will be back: <track id="27" name="Boss (Blue Womb - Hush)" intro="Afterbirth/Morituros (dead womb boss) intro.ogg" path="Afterbirth/Morituros (dead womb boss) Loop.ogg" loop="true" />

@Amity Thank you, you were right, I missed the utero track. Well I was rushing to get it updated for you all xD. New version released that fixes it!

would it be possible to choose which tracks to leave untouched? like i would love to keep hush theme from rebirth for example

@DarkJuda - I can't stand Ridiculon, and I plan to make a version just like that! Classic DannyB + Mudeth + Repentance only where there is nothing else. In fact its the version I will use personally. I was gong to do it here but popular demand was the way it is now with Ridiculon for new stuff.

I need to get a copy of the original .oggs for the Antibirth mod. I'm assuimg I can extract it from the mod, but DarkJuda if you know somewhre they are, or somehwre Mudeth is posting his new work, please let me know.

@Amity - not sure. I'll look into it. I have experienced sometimes a floor's music not playing with this mod, and I have dug and dug into why and there is no reason it should happen. The game code is not modified at all, only the audio files. At this point I simply believe that modifying Isaac music is simply slightly unstable at the game level.

Not getting any music in the womb any reason why that would be?

I would love to see a music mod with:

- Classic Isaac music in every chapter/boss fight/rooms classic had
- Adding the Antibrith tracks to fill the gaps everywhere they are meant to be.
- Adding the new tracks Mudeth is creating.
- Repentence music only where there is no other music already (maybe there won't be).

In that order.
The only downside would be that some of mudeth tracks would never play, like innoncence glitched. But the menu soundtrack mod that allows to randomize soundracks is a nice workaround to make up for it from time to time.

I'm really tired of ridiculon soundrack. Even if it's very well done and with high quality,, it justs never fited the game for me.

To all, thank you for your feedback. The Mod has been updated to support Repentance, and by popular demand (with a 1 vote victory margin), this mod will keep the original DannyB music in place and keep the new Ridiculon music for the Repentance areas. I will be updating soon to make a few alternate version of this Mod for the other options given, but I gotta sleep now xD

also go for option 2 just for artist consistency, and allow an antibirth+ music mod (preferrably the one mudeth is making) to be made by someone else.

update repentance NOW DOES so cmere pspspsps

Go for Option 3.

I recant my statement about this mod breaking: some other mod was doing it instead.

Though still, I want to keep the Alt Floor Music the way they are, and to keep it Repentance OST.

I'd say go with the repentance tracks. Gives me that awesome DannyB ost for the levels and fights I fell in love with while allowing the repentance tracks to carve out a place amongst the new content.

> (3) use the original antibirth tracks (i like the idea, but the music also isnt very dannyb)

I'd rather you kept those tracks.

keep the repentance tracks, they're far better than the rebirth tracks and don't deserve replacing

option 1 and 2 are both pretty good compromises.

I think option 2 would be good.

just keep the repentance tracks

and also... while i would personally prefer finding thematically appropriate music from other games, i would also not mind recycling. whatever you feel is best will be good enough for me.