Wooooooooooow
Wait are you serious? Are you serious? You literally name shamed me in a completely different thread board, and then told the creator he should (in an act of power abuse) ban and block me from the board for saying that his skin isnt good enough

You have issues. And I dont get where this is coming from
It's 2017. Nobody likes white knights.

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Originally posted by Delta:

Wooooooooooow
Wait are you serious? Are you serious? You literally name shamed me in a completely different thread board, and then told the creator he should (in an act of power abuse) ban and block me from the board for saying that his skin isnt good enough

You have issues. And I dont get where this is coming from

Not as many issues you do, buddy. Cause you have not offered at least one single thing to improve it. All you did was depreciate it again and again. Critiquing is a double sided coin, you can offer things that are wrong with something, BUT a Great critique is one that also tries to offer ways to improve it, something you not once offered, all of what you said can be condensed into this. "This is ♥♥♥♥, gtfo."

Probably because I dont give a ♥♥♥♥ on whether or not its good, all I care about and all anyone should care about is whether or not its good enough to get into the game, because thats all that matters here
You are not being realisitc here, you are letting emotions get you into a a flame war and its pathetic
If it doesnt make it into the game then whats the point of any of us praising it? It has no chance of making it into the halloween round for obvious reasons, and its obviously not up to the same quality that most of the items on the workshop are up to, so I dont understand whats not constructive about me telling him to work on it until the winter when it actually has any chance whatsoever

Also this is common knowledge, but this many rounds in most people dont look favorably upon items that are just re skins. People want unique helmets, and now more than ever. Unique helmets with unique skins. These newer skins dont really blend well with the vanilla assets. Just take a look at hydroid on any darker coloration with his current workshop helmet

Originally posted by Delta:

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Not as many issues you do, buddy. Cause you have not offered at least one single thing to improve it. All you did was depreciate it again and again. Critiquing is a double sided coin, you can offer things that are wrong with something, BUT a Great critique is one that also tries to offer ways to improve it, something you not once offered, all of what you said can be condensed into this. "This is ♥♥♥♥, gtfo."

Probably because I dont give a ♥♥♥♥ on whether or not its good, all I care about and all anyone should care about is whether or not its good enough to get into the game, because thats all that matters here
You are not being realisitc here, you are letting emotions get you into a a flame war and its pathetic
If it doesnt make it into the game then whats the point of any of us praising it? It has no chance of making it into the halloween round for obvious reasons, and its obviously not up to the same quality that most of the items on the workshop are up to, so I dont understand whats not constructive about me telling him to work on it until the winter when it actually has any chance whatsoever

Also this is common knowledge, but this many rounds in most people dont look favorably upon items that are just re skins. People want unique helmets, and now more than ever. Unique helmets with unique skins. These newer skins dont really blend well with the vanilla assets. Just take a look at hydroid on any darker coloration with his current workshop helmet

See, why didn't you open up with this from the first place, this right here is a proper critique. You have to also realize that this is also very much a passion of art as well than simply machine churning out items. Someone worked on this. Where else would one really be able to post it, to get the same amount of feedback that causes others to improve their design on here? I mean yes it is very unlikely that this will win, however, this doesn't mean it can't be improved upon to make it a more viable submission for later. See I am offering my own critique. Keep this in mind for next time.

The ♥♥♥♥ happened here?

Originally posted by Samus Aran:

The ♥♥♥♥ happened here?

Hijacked thread I recomend the creator delete topic or unpin it and startagain.

Originally posted by -AKEVA-BANSHEE-:

Originally posted by Samus Aran:

The ♥♥♥♥ happened here?

Hijacked thread I recomend the creator delete topic or unpin it and startagain.

I wouldnt mind it

But he renamed it too late. You can read the OP in my reply quote

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Originally posted by Delta:

Probably because I dont give a ♥♥♥♥ on whether or not its good, all I care about and all anyone should care about is whether or not its good enough to get into the game, because thats all that matters here
You are not being realisitc here, you are letting emotions get you into a a flame war and its pathetic
If it doesnt make it into the game then whats the point of any of us praising it? It has no chance of making it into the halloween round for obvious reasons, and its obviously not up to the same quality that most of the items on the workshop are up to, so I dont understand whats not constructive about me telling him to work on it until the winter when it actually has any chance whatsoever

Also this is common knowledge, but this many rounds in most people dont look favorably upon items that are just re skins. People want unique helmets, and now more than ever. Unique helmets with unique skins. These newer skins dont really blend well with the vanilla assets. Just take a look at hydroid on any darker coloration with his current workshop helmet

See, why didn't you open up with this from the first place, this right here is a proper critique. You have to also realize that this is also very much a passion of art as well than simply machine churning out items. Someone worked on this. Where else would one really be able to post it, to get the same amount of feedback that causes others to improve their design on here? I mean yes it is very unlikely that this will win, however, this doesn't mean it can't be improved upon to make it a more viable submission for later. See I am offering my own critique. Keep this in mind for next time.

THIS IS LITERALLY ALONG THE SAME LINES OF WHAT I SAID (if not more abrasive)

Like I mentioned before, you have issues and you take everything way too seriously

Originally posted by Delta:

-snip-

I mean sure Negative opinion, that is your right, however, you also take the consequences that will possibly follow. You made it seem like this of the quality of stuff like Volatile Rhino Skin, which it isn't. You didn't acknowledge the effort put into it, it just needs more effort put into it. Just leave it at that, without having a long winded depreciating comment without providing ANY pointers of things to change. Keep it simple.

"Ok besides the fact that this is no where near the quality of most items and so im sorry has no chance of getting picked, can people stop posting there stuff to workshop right now? DE already said the next tennogen is halloween themed. You have double no chance because its not halloween themed. Dont upload it. Work on it, Make it better. Have it ready for christmas"

This is not critiquing, cause you have provided nothing in this comment and it comes across as very demoralizing. You are treating it like there was no effort put into it. Effort is greater than chances of getting in, this is a fact. Because at the end of the day these people are artists, not machines for your amusement. Yes, it may not be perfection, but there was indeed effort put into it. Be respectful with critquing other's works. This will be the last reply I make on the subject.

Ok lets break this down bit

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

I mean sure Negative opinion, that is your right, however, you also take the consequences that will possibly follow.

You mean the consequences that you enact upon me. I get flak for what you deem as controversial. You dont see a problem with that, or how petty that sounds?

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

You made it seem like this of the quality of stuff like Volatile Rhino Skin, which it isn't.

You really love accusing me of saying ♥♥♥♥ I never say

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

You didn't acknowledge the effort put into it, it just needs more effort put into it.

Because like I said above I dont give a crap about that, thats not going to help out the creator. All I care about is whether or not its going to get into the game BECAUSE THATS ALL THAT MATTERS.

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Just leave it at that, without having a long winded depreciating comment without providing ANY pointers of things to change.

Judging from the fact that you wrote 3 "Long winded" paragraphs all about me and my one "long winded" paragraph and then proceeded to make a thread where you completely throw shade at me after the fact. I find this very very hypocritical of you to say

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Keep it simple.

It's not good enough

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

"Ok besides the fact that this is no where near the quality of most items and so im sorry has no chance of getting picked, can people stop posting there stuff to workshop right now? DE already said the next tennogen is halloween themed. You have double no chance because its not halloween themed. Dont upload it. Work on it, Make it better. Have it ready for christmas"

This is not critiquing, cause you have provided nothing in this comment

Says you
And nobody else

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

and it comes across as very demoralizing.

TO YOU
And nobody else
You have thin skin Adachi. I'm sure the creator either doesnt give a ♥♥♥♥ about what I have to say, will take it to heart and make a better skin or will think im an ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ and respond accordingly without you holding there hand

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

You are treating it like there was no effort put into it.

Effort doesnt get the skin into the game

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Effort is greater than chances of getting in, this is a fact.

OH REALLY?
Oh look at that, a fact
People can be so clusmy, dropping them on the floor like that

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Because at the end of the day these people are artists, not machines for your amusement.

So what you are saying is that all artists are snobs with thin skin and that we shouldnt criticize there work because it might hurt there feelings?
Also "Machines for your amusement" You make no sense

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Yes, it may not be perfection, but there was indeed effort put into it.

Ok?

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

Be respectful with critquing other's works.

I was.
Be respectful when critiquing other peoples critique. You where not, you completely insulted me multiple times and completely misconstrue much of everything ive said in that original comment

Please try to deny that. It wouldnt be hard to prove you wrong

Originally posted by Adachi Ame:

This will be the last reply I make on the subject.

Dont make promises you cant keep

ha this guy played halo xD

The hell is going on?

Originally posted by SwankyPants:

The hell is going on?

Go read the main comment section of the mod
Then go read my first comment on this thread with the previous thread description quote
Decide for yourself

Originally posted by Delta:

Originally posted by SwankyPants:

The hell is going on?

Go read the main comment section of the mod
Then go read my first comment on this thread with the previous thread description quote
Decide for yourself

Hmm, yeah. Maybe your going a little too far.

Originally posted by SwankyPants:

Originally posted by Delta:

Go read the main comment section of the mod
Then go read my first comment on this thread with the previous thread description quote
Decide for yourself

Hmm, yeah. Maybe your going a little too far.

Too far my ass. Sorry I dont feel like joining the echo chamber, I like to be a little productive on these forums

Originally posted by Delta:

Originally posted by SwankyPants:

Hmm, yeah. Maybe your going a little too far.

Too far my ass. Sorry I dont feel like joining the echo chamber, I like to be a little productive on these forums

Productive? All of THAT was productive? Maybe if you suggested hoe to make it better or something along the lines of that, that would be productive. THIS however, seems pretty far from that.