my idea for this weapon is it would be a random potion every time and the stats would be
+50% recovery
-25% attack speed
the potion effects would be like fire,mad milk,ect.

I had another Idea, I was thinking it could be a throw able item (like mad milk) that would lower a enemy's damage and shrink them

Originally posted by gnome-ing around:

I had another Idea, I was thinking it could be a throw able item (like mad milk) that would lower a enemy's damage and shrink them

I was thinking the opposite.

The Cauldron Concoction
level 45 Potion
Slot: secondary

on drinking: Scout becomes the size of a giant scout from MvM gaining 200% more health and dealing 75% more damage
+ On kill: refill 25% ammo for your primary
- Restricted to melee on activation
- When the effect ends you get stunned for 5 seconds

Stats

GOOD
25% chance of minicrits for 5 seconds
25% chance of "bonk" for 10 seconds
25% chance for unlimited jumps for 10 seconds
20% chance of speed boost for 7 seconds
4% chance of CRITZ for 5

BAD
1% chance of bleeding for 5 seconds :/

hmmm very interesting

I have returned!
Use Bonk as a base
Pros:
-Upon drinking: Gain ubercharge effect for five seconds. Effect is prolonged by .7 seconds upon kill while under its effects

Cons:
-Restricts user to only using their melee.
-User is marked for death upon the effect's end.

"Magickus crappicus"

This probably would either completely overshadow or be completely overshadowed by the Bonk, but I thought it was a fun spin on this classic weapon type. However, this could also be super fun as a more aggressive and defensive item for scout. You could really just do some stuff that scout shouldn't be allowed to using this item and I think that that holds some neat potential