Tyrone has meddled with the code again and now mods cannot remove smelted trinkets as of REP+ version 1.9.7.12, making Hieroglyph not work as intended!
(The API itself is broken... again. What a bummer.)

I strongly recommend you avoid using the Rep+ while using mods from now on, since this is an error that affects all mods involving trinkets, such as Retribution, Fiend Folio, and other large-scale mods!

-Best regards, Giant Disgusting King Blue Baby