Heres a idea

On kill bottle will break

Pros

When bottle is broken
+15 damage
On hit will cause bleeding for 5 seconds

Cons

When bottle is not broken
-25 damage
-10 bullet resistance

first

how about no stats and it's just a reskin?

Pro:
-60% Damage on explosions (can be used for Sticky jumps)

Cons:
-50% Damage

OR

Pro:
+15HP on Taunt (like kritzkrieg taunt)

Cons:
-25HP
Wearer takes +50 Damage by fire, when equipped

when bottle is broken gain 25% of charge on kill. no random crits.

Originally posted by Gaige™:

how about no stats and it's just a reskin?

Yeah I agree

Originally posted by |X| Commander Soldier |X|:

Originally posted by Gaige™:

how about no stats and it's just a reskin?

Yeah I agree

we really dont need reskin we have so many!!!!! what we need is a new weapon!!!!!

Pro: + 20% damage
+ on kill: demo gets mini crits for 2 seconds

Cons: - 25% Slower firing speed

In my opinion its balanced and might work good with the Loch and Load?

Originally posted by Reginald P. Moneybags:

Pro: + 20% damage
+ on kill: demo gets mini crits for 2 seconds

Cons: - 25% Slower firing speed

In my opinion its balanced and might work good with the Loch and Load?

Put -no random crits and its fine :)

Originally posted by Also Known as Kevin:

Originally posted by Reginald P. Moneybags:

Pro: + 20% damage
+ on kill: demo gets mini crits for 2 seconds

Cons: - 25% Slower firing speed

In my opinion its balanced and might work good with the Loch and Load?

Put -no random crits and its fine :)

yeah that would work when I posted I just thought that would be nerfing it a bit too much or instead a slower arming speed?

Right-Click to consume for 40HP, takes 30 seconds to recharge. Gets rid of afterburn.
Cannot be crit boosted (random crits still exist), -20% swing speed. -25% damage penalty.

Originally posted by ButtonBreakingGamer:

Right-Click to consume for 40HP, takes 30 seconds to recharge. Gets rid of afterburn.
Cannot be crit boosted (random crits still exist), -20% swing speed. -25% damage penalty.

That might actually work.

Pros:
First hit does +25% damage as the bottle breaks
Hits after the bottle is broken do 5 seconds of bleed on target

Cons:
Being damaged while holding the unbroken bottle has a chance to break in your hand causing 50 damage with 5 seconds of bleed
Bottle can only be broken on enemies
+15% melee weakness while bottle is broken

Just Make it the Demoman's Version of the Market Gardener

Originally posted by PiranhaFire69:

Just Make it the Demoman's Version of the Market Gardener

I agree

+Crits on explosive jump.
-No Random critical hits.