hmmm, here's my view
Gain "Main Thunda" by dealing 350 damage.
When full, alt-fire to gain mini-crits for all weapons for 8 seconds.
+30% bullet spread
No random critical hits
-10% damage penalty

What about
Gain "Main Thunda" by dealing 350 damage.
When full, alt-fire to gain mini-crits for all weapons for 8 seconds and 50% faster reload time
+25% bullet spread
+30% more damage
-90% clip size (1 bullet)

Originally posted by Gourd of Death (G.O.D.):

What about
Gain "Main Thunda" by dealing 350 damage.
When full, alt-fire to gain mini-crits for all weapons for 8 seconds and 50% faster reload time
+25% bullet spread
+30% more damage
-90% clip size (1 bullet)

350 damage?
n00bs wouldn't get 350 in one life.

Originally posted by Sims Legit:

Originally posted by Gourd of Death (G.O.D.):

What about
Gain "Main Thunda" by dealing 350 damage.
When full, alt-fire to gain mini-crits for all weapons for 8 seconds and 50% faster reload time
+25% bullet spread
+30% more damage
-90% clip size (1 bullet)

350 damage?
n00bs wouldn't get 350 in one life.

I like the idea of a huge 1 damage meat shot so 150 or 200 for the "Main Thunda"
So 1 or 2 good hits

>Valve nerfed the soda popper for a reason, to prevent ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ mini-crits, please shut up about the mini-crit boost.
:)

How about a defensive buff? Been a while since Scout had one of those. Deal 200 damage and get 7 seconds of 20% damage reduction, as well as crit and mini-crt immunity.

Originally posted by Thway the AetherKnight:

How about a defensive buff? Been a while since Scout had one of those. Deal 200 damage and get 7 seconds of 20% damage reduction, as well as crit and mini-crt immunity.

The Crit-a-Cola exists for the minicrit buff and the soda popper was nerfed because of its minicrit buff. So I do think that this is a good idea. But carrying such a heavy weapon for such a weak scout has to have some movement penalties. How about
-10% movement speed?

Originally posted by charlie:

Originally posted by Thway the AetherKnight:

How about a defensive buff? Been a while since Scout had one of those. Deal 200 damage and get 7 seconds of 20% damage reduction, as well as crit and mini-crt immunity.

The Crit-a-Cola exists for the minicrit buff and the soda popper was nerfed because of its minicrit buff. So I do think that this is a good idea. But carrying such a heavy weapon for such a weak scout has to have some movement penalties. How about
-10% movement speed?

Oh okay thanks for reading my post...

My personal stats would be
65% Extra Damage
Quarterd Range
40% Damage Resistance Against Soldier,Demo,and Heavy
-40% Damage Resistance Against Scout,Sniper,Spy

This weapon would really bring the "thunder against heavy classes.

Also 33% Less Clipsize

Sounds reasonable. I really wanna see this implemented.

Originally posted by Thway the AetherKnight:

Sounds reasonable. I really wanna see this implemented.

Not gonna happen, as I posted and many other TF2 vets, the soda-popper was nerfed for a reason.Valve doesn't agree with weapons that generate crits and have no plans to make any more, phlog is for pyro and pyro can't move as fast as a scunt so he didn't have mmph removed.

Originally posted by Thway the AetherKnight:

How about a defensive buff? Been a while since Scout had one of those. Deal 200 damage and get 7 seconds of 20% damage reduction, as well as crit and mini-crt immunity.

I was talking about this idea that some of the others agree with.

Guys, this is not the phlog. :P