Trang cửa hàng
Starbound
Tất cả Thảo luận Ảnh chụp Tranh ảnh Phát sóng Video Workshop Tin tức Hướng dẫn Đánh giá
Starbound >  Workshop > Workshop của firubii > Hoenn Trumpet > Thảo luận
Hoenn Trumpet
Mô tả Thảo luận1 Bình luận50 Ghi chú thay đổi
Jorhlok 20 Thg12, 2016 @ 1:38am
Out of tune
If you switch from the hoenn trumpet to the regular one -- or any other instrument, for that matter -- while playing a song you'll hear how severely out of tune it is. In fact, each ogg file seems to be the C below the note its name is. This tuning.config brings that in line:

{ "fadeout" : 0.1, "mapping" : { //basic piano key index (+20) "108" : { "f" : 4186.01 }, "107" : { "f" : 3951.07 }, "106" : { "f" : 3729.31 }, "105" : { "f" : 3520.00 }, "104" : { "f" : 3322.44 }, "103" : { "f" : 3135.96 }, "102" : { "f" : 2959.96 }, "101" : { "f" : 2793.83 }, "100" : { "f" : 2637.02 }, "99" : { "f" : 2489.02 }, "98" : { "f" : 2349.32 }, "97" : { "f" : 2217.46 }, "96" : { "f" : 2093.00, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a7.ogg" }, "95" : { "f" : 1975.53 }, "94" : { "f" : 1864.66 }, "93" : { "f" : 1760.00 }, "92" : { "f" : 1661.22 }, "91" : { "f" : 1567.98 }, "90" : { "f" : 1479.98 }, "89" : { "f" : 1396.91 }, "88" : { "f" : 1318.51 }, "87" : { "f" : 1244.51 }, "86" : { "f" : 1174.66 }, "85" : { "f" : 1108.73 }, "84" : { "f" : 1046.50, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a6.ogg" }, "83" : { "f" : 987.767 }, "82" : { "f" : 932.328 }, "81" : { "f" : 880.000 }, "80" : { "f" : 830.609 }, "79" : { "f" : 783.991 }, "78" : { "f" : 739.989 }, "77" : { "f" : 698.456 }, "76" : { "f" : 659.255 }, "75" : { "f" : 622.254 }, "74" : { "f" : 587.330 }, "73" : { "f" : 554.365 }, "72" : { "f" : 523.251, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a5.ogg" }, "71" : { "f" : 493.883 }, "70" : { "f" : 466.164 }, "69" : { "f" : 440.000 }, "68" : { "f" : 415.305 }, "67" : { "f" : 391.995 }, "66" : { "f" : 369.994 }, "65" : { "f" : 349.228 }, "64" : { "f" : 329.628 }, "63" : { "f" : 311.127 }, "62" : { "f" : 293.665 }, "61" : { "f" : 277.183 }, "60" : { "f" : 261.626, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a4.ogg" }, "59" : { "f" : 246.942 }, "58" : { "f" : 233.082 }, "57" : { "f" : 220.000 }, "56" : { "f" : 207.652 }, "55" : { "f" : 195.998 }, "54" : { "f" : 184.997 }, "53" : { "f" : 174.614 }, "52" : { "f" : 164.814 }, "51" : { "f" : 155.563 }, "50" : { "f" : 146.832 }, "49" : { "f" : 138.591 }, "48" : { "f" : 130.813, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a3.ogg" }, "47" : { "f" : 123.471 }, "46" : { "f" : 116.541 }, "45" : { "f" : 110.000 }, "44" : { "f" : 103.826 }, "43" : { "f" : 97.9989 }, "42" : { "f" : 92.4986 }, "41" : { "f" : 87.3071 }, "40" : { "f" : 82.4069 }, "39" : { "f" : 77.7817 }, "38" : { "f" : 73.4162 }, "37" : { "f" : 69.2957 }, "36" : { "f" : 65.4064, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a2.ogg" }, "35" : { "f" : 61.7354 }, "34" : { "f" : 58.2705 }, "33" : { "f" : 55.0000 }, "32" : { "f" : 51.9131 }, "31" : { "f" : 48.9994 }, "30" : { "f" : 46.2493 }, "29" : { "f" : 43.6535 }, "28" : { "f" : 41.2034 }, "27" : { "f" : 38.8909 }, "26" : { "f" : 36.7081 }, "25" : { "f" : 34.6478 }, "24" : { "f" : 32.7032, "file" : "/sfx/instruments/$instrument$/a1.ogg" }, "23" : { "f" : 30.8677 }, "22" : { "f" : 29.1352 }, "21" : { "f" : 27.5000 } } }
Lần sửa cuối bởi Jorhlok; 20 Thg12, 2016 @ 1:49am
< >
Đang hiển thị 1-5 trong 5 bình luận
firubii  [nhà phát triển] 22 Thg12, 2016 @ 2:25pm 
It's not out of tune. I ripped the sound directly from the game files. It just sounds different from the regular trumpet.
#1
Jorhlok 22 Thg12, 2016 @ 3:03pm 
No, it really is out of tune. Each of those files contains a C note, not an A note that the tuning.config expects. An A note is some sort of power of two up or down of 440 Hz.

There's three different tests you can do in audacity with one of the files.
1. Select a section after the first bit where it's unstable and select the effect "Pitch Change." It does an analysis to estimate the frequency of the note. It's not accurate on the low pitch files a2.ogg and below because it's detecting too much of the harmonics.

2. Add a new track along side the old one and generate a sine wave of the target frequency. That's those decimal values in tuning.config. If you generate 440 Hz (A4) next to the sound in a4.ogg, you'll hear a chord, not the two sounds merging together as one. You're going to need the volume to be the same for both sounds.

3. Measure the wavelength. It's most accurate if you do more than one period.
Number of periods / total length of time in seconds = frequency in Hz

Many applications that take sound samples like this assume C as the base note as it's typically regarded as the first note in an octave. It's the "do" in "do re mi fa so la ti do." This is why it was no surprise to me how simple the problem and solution are.
#2
Jorhlok 27 Thg12, 2016 @ 10:12pm 
Well if anybody's interested they can now subscribe to this to put it in tune.
https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=827912235
This only contains the tuning.config above.
#3
firubii  [nhà phát triển] 28 Thg12, 2016 @ 10:40am 
I'll fix it if it's actually out of tune. Thanks for fixing it, by the way.

EDIT: Now uploading to the Workshop.

EDIT 2: Uploaded.
Lần sửa cuối bởi firubii; 28 Thg12, 2016 @ 10:50am
#4
Jorhlok 28 Thg12, 2016 @ 8:37pm 
Neat. I got rid of my fixer mod since it's useless now. Cheers!
#5
< >
Đang hiển thị 1-5 trong 5 bình luận
Mỗi trang: 1530 50