Wreckfest

Wreckfest

The Very TrackPack
Some feedback
Overall great work with the tracks! But the visual quality seems to vary a lot. Would be great if you could revisit old tracks.

One suggestion, imo you could try using high-res photograhps instead of 3D mountains and other 3D background screnery. Like official tracks. Would help giving each track unique, high fidelity look, and make look more like official.

Although, if photo resolution is lower than official tracks, then it won't create the illusion of it being part of the track. Official tracks look very convincing with this way, the photos they used are simply spot-on, like they are part of actual scenery.

I understand that suitable photos with high enough resolution might be hard to come by. But it might really raise the bar of visual quality, without having to use more 3D assets.

Is it currently possible to mod this, by using 2 mods in the same time? Other for background, other for tracks?
Last edited by Hyperion Biga; 14 Jul, 2018 @ 9:33pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
Hyperion Biga 14 Jul, 2018 @ 11:15pm 
Also, some feedback about the latest track, it's hilarious :D And looks mostly awesome.

Some suggestions:

- Maybe the ramp could be a bit smoother, so that cars who don't make the jump could climb slowly back up (in the figure 8-variant, many cars gets stuck already on first lap, after failing the big jump)

- Perhaps some texture inside the tunnels, that would show less apparent "tiling"?

- Water doesn't look very natural :/ I guess Wreckfest limitation. A reflective blue surface without "waves" texture could be better? So it would just reflect skybox. Or just flat blue surface. Because it becomes apparent the waves don't move

Last edited by Hyperion Biga; 14 Jul, 2018 @ 11:17pm
The Very End  [developer] 15 Jul, 2018 @ 12:14am 
Thanks for suggestions!

The quality varies a lot yes haha! Two years ago I started learning 3ds max, and now two years later I am still learning, but the experience has helped me improve a lot. I intend to backtrack and make tracks look more equal, just takes time hehe.

The background mountain with picture - sure, that is worth to use more time on. As you say, it looks great for BB, so it is just a matter of learning good usage for it, place it right and learn. Will try to utilize this more on new tracks.
You could mod in backgrounds by adding them to a sky box mod, then use that sky box in the tracks.

As for tunnel, agree totally. Should probably try to fund either a totally seamless rock texture or concrete texture (would require some smoothing).

I can get the wather to move, but it will only move in one direction. A side result to this is that it get more green (as you can see in the moving river below the bridge). Is that preferable or would maybe a black and reflective surface be a better choise here? Not sure myself hehe.
Hyperion Biga 15 Jul, 2018 @ 12:58am 
Hard to say. Now it catches the eye, but if if was just flat blue maybe it blends in better? And looks more like sea. Or same kind of texture as now, but weaker waves (less opacity).

Just guessing here :D

Concrete might work for the tunnel, so it doesn't matter if there is "tiling". Or seamless rock, but with concrete tiles it wouldn't matter if 1 texture is repeated, because concrete tiles look all same

Don't know why the AI fails the jump, could that be fixed with AI line? Many cars get stuck in the "pit" under the big jump, and try to climb back up. But it's too steep to climb, maybe because the edge is too sharp to climb overr? So if it was a bit round, could they maybe get (slowly) back on track and continue race? Or create some "side road" that leads back on top

I love the big jump though, official tracks should have some tracks like this, they look great but in comparison are a bit boring tbh
Last edited by Hyperion Biga; 15 Jul, 2018 @ 1:04am
The Very End  [developer] 15 Jul, 2018 @ 3:18am 
Will try out some black / blue reflective texture next week and see if that works better :)
Will also play around with concrete textures and see what works best.

There is a small side road on the jump, but poor AI has never been interested in learning how to avoid or use escape paths. Maybe I could extend the ramp a Bit? Like a metal mesh that extends a couple of meters backwards to catch the AIs?
Also, high B class AIs and A class seems to manage the jump. Low B and C does have a hard time (which that extra ramp might help with).
Last edited by The Very End; 15 Jul, 2018 @ 3:18am
Hyperion Biga 15 Jul, 2018 @ 7:22am 
Ah, I must have missed the side road. Too bad AI missed it too :D But keen to see what you come up with!
The Very End  [developer] 16 Jul, 2018 @ 9:44am 
Uhm... look at this lmao: https://s33.postimg.cc/o20s88fi7/Untitled.jpg
Not sure if reflective water is such a great idea hahah! Will try to see if I can make it somewhat better, but that looks... jesus it looks like something.
(tested with just black color to see how it works with a fully reflective surface).
Last edited by The Very End; 16 Jul, 2018 @ 9:45am
Hyperion Biga 16 Jul, 2018 @ 11:22am 
Hahha no :D Reflection quality of Wreckfest isn't enough for this idea maybe? Thanks for trying though. The blue under it looks good though, maybe if it was just that? Blue surface. From far distance might look "watery" enough?

One other thing, been playing this track a lot, and noticed the performance is clearly worse than in any other of your modtracks :/ Tried to disable grass totally and put less cars, still get pretty bad FPS drops (under 60).

Where as I can use 24 cars with Ultra grass in most other TVTP tracks, and get solid 60 fps. There is few others TVTP tracks with slight drops, unless I put Grass or cars down, but not as bad as this. Bit of shame, since I can use ultra settings in official tracks with always 60 fps (sometimes comes pretty close to 60, triple screen is demanding.. but always stays over it)
Last edited by Hyperion Biga; 16 Jul, 2018 @ 11:29am
The Very End  [developer] 16 Jul, 2018 @ 11:45am 
Maybe!

Yeah noticed that too, and tried several methods to improve it;
* reduced resolution of texture and decal maps
* reduced grass
* removed all trees
* removed spectators
* removed general objects
* used (and using) several anti portals, which basically is a rendering limit to increase performance

Sadly it does not seem to be related to this. I suspect that the lights might be the culprint, but will test more tomorrow. Hopefully I can pinpoint one thing that increased performance.
Last edited by The Very End; 16 Jul, 2018 @ 11:46am
Hyperion Biga 16 Jul, 2018 @ 1:47pm 
Hmm odd, would think it's one of those :/ Hope you solve the mystery
Daystar 17 Jul, 2018 @ 1:30am 
I get horrible fps on SCA tracks, full circuit & derby.. I get about 10 fps ughh.. maybe to many blend textures?
The Very End  [developer] 17 Jul, 2018 @ 1:33am 
It has less blend textures than both redwood ring and orange speedway, so don't think that is the issue. Got to find the culprint, just not sure what it is - yet.
The Very End  [developer] 17 Jul, 2018 @ 7:26am 
Alright! So, I think I pinpointed the problem. Seems I had a bit too big fences, so splitted them into smaller objects (you won't see it, as it's the same amount of fences on track) and my FPS stayed higher and more consistent. Will play around and fix this and other small things, and come back with a patch in the upcoming days (hopefully before weekend if not too much stuff happening). Will also - since you guys are awesome, do a snow layout of Sca because ... why not :D
Last edited by The Very End; 17 Jul, 2018 @ 7:27am
Daystar 17 Jul, 2018 @ 5:04pm 
Awesome! I will check it out later today! Thx for listening Tor =)
Hyperion Biga 18 Jul, 2018 @ 11:23am 
The tunnels look MUCH MUCH better now! Awesome! Makes the track look MUCH more polished and official track quality. The difference is amazing.

Still think the water could be improved, the texture is (imo) too high contrast, too detailed. Just dark blue with very little or no waves texture would imo look better.

Same with Assetto Corsa mods (which also doesn't have water effects), I've seen best water comes when it's "played down" and just one simplistic dark blue color. So it doesn't draw attention. Water can look almost like one blue tint, from upwards and far distance (like in this tracks it's seen, from this corner before the tunnel)

Image examples:

http://www.horizont.fi/horizont/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/cr4-Horizont.fi_Jyri_M%C3%A4kinen_kuortaneen_j%C3%A4rvi_ja_lapuan_joki_2016-900x630.jpg

http://holycityhelicopters.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Website-7.jpg

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/A5qcNDw-6v0/maxresdefault.jpg

Third thing, I still get a bit low FPS compared to your other tracks :/ Even with grass on medium. But big improvement over previous version.

Then one thing, I don't know if you want to keep this faithful to some classic track? But on the full layout, taking the left tunnel route (that leads up to the lake view, talked earlier) it is very narrow. And stays narrow for long time. There is no chances for overtaking, and it kind of creates very cautious driving style. Perhaps AI can get even stuck here?

Could there be layout, where the left tunnel is just tarmac, no armco fences making it narrow? Or armco only in some parts or wider road overall, so it's mostly higher speed, with room for overtakes and battles? Line of cars driving in this "tube" for long time, unable to overtake, isn't as much fun as battles and options to take inside/outside line. Maybe wider left route could be optional layout? Or the narrow armco would be only in some parts.

But overall great work, I can always take the right tunnel anyway. My only issue is the water texture now, and if you could find few more FPS maybe?
Last edited by Hyperion Biga; 18 Jul, 2018 @ 11:30am
The Very End  [developer] 18 Jul, 2018 @ 11:32am 
Thanks for giving feedback, it helps a lot both on the result also to understand what people think :)

Yeah the water needs work, tried looking for some sea textures but guess I will just have to make something myself that is in the right color range.

I think some of the fps loss is due to the size of the track. Larger areas has to be covered by fences, props and so on, and coupled with all those other small things it all adds up. Hopefully next track I make will be less size / object orientated, which shoukd demand less performance.

As for the layour; someone asked for an faster layout on the right side tunnel by removing the narrowing fence "bulk". What if I make a layout with that, and as well opens up the left one? What I can do is to remove the fences, opening up the road a lot. It will still be risky as the outside of the road path is extremely bumpy.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
Per page: 1530 50