Hearts of Iron IV

Hearts of Iron IV

Total War Mod
richfed 21 Mar, 2022 @ 8:05pm
Single Player and Total War
First of all, I have loved this mod and it is the only way I can play - and really enjoy the experience. I always found it to be quite historical and sensible. I looked forward to No Step Back's release with great anticipation and was anxious to see what you guys who design & code would do with it. One of the more disappointing gaming experiences I have ever had.

It is my assumption, based on reading the Discord comments - and I could be wrong - that the focus of the game has shifted drastically in favor of multi-player. NSB had some nice enhancements and I thought you would make them better. MP, I am sure, is much more passionate than a nice quiet sit down with a cup of coffee and play the way I want and when I want. For me, it's relaxing. I am not interested in making only fighters & tanks. I suppose that might work in MP where the competitive edge takes over and it's win at all costs. I prefer to play a balanced game, simulating what the leader of the country had to deal with ... juggling economics, diplomacy, manpower, equipment and strategy.

So, I don't get why the research was given a 16% increase. Then you added an extra slot sort of acknowledging a player might need some help. It doesn't work. If I play as Civilian with the slider all the way up for my country, it still takes longer than it did BEFORE the changes. There's just not enough time to get it all together.

I play as Germany. I attempt the invasion of Denmark [which took a total of ONE day in real life] and Norway. My feeble Navy has to establish naval supremacy in the Baltic/Denmark, but what do I find? A 64 ship British fleet effectively denying me any chance of success. Meanwhile, I had 3 paratroop divisions all geared up to go with Kurt Student [who I had to jump through hoops to get] as their leader. They dropped on Norway's west coast and were met with THREE french tank divisions, a cavalry division, and an infantry division. They lasted about 10 seconds.

I don't believe the game is playable - to my satisfaction, anyway - in SP. It's fun in the buildup, but I just can't get to the point of having a chance unless I were to fall into the 50 factories on tanks, 50 factories on fighters, and to hell with the rest. You plan & plan all the while knowing it ain't going to go well

And then, to add insult to injury, you take the free Wehrmacht/Luftwaffe focus away. Why? There was a choice of "neither" if a player wanted to go that route.

I just think that the game needs to afford a SP a good gaming experience, as well. Vanilla is like playing in slo-mo for the first 4 years. Total War changed all that for me, but it seems to be drifting away from SP.

That's my rant. Sorry I had to do it.

Thank you for all the work you guys have done over the past few years.

PS - I still hate the protest in the factories event[s]. :steamfacepalm:
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
Homuya 20 Apr, 2022 @ 8:24pm 
If you'd like we could play coop and I can teach you some tricks.

I personally just war Sweden and go through that, apart from that you can pretty much wreck any navy with naval bombers.

When im Germany I usually war and puppet Italy and pretty much being entire Europe under my reign (even Spain) and puppet as much as possible and then war the soviets in around 41 still.
Bramja 23 Apr, 2022 @ 8:45am 
Hey, thanks for your feedback.

Looking at Discord could indeed give the impression that the mod is very MP oriented, but this a bit the nature of Discord, where players come to discuss and communicate for MP games. This gives a bit of a skewed idea.

The other issue is that we often don't communicate enough of what we add.
To give an idea, I add to the mod as part of the team quite a bit and never play MP. The last months things have been added/are being added that is mostly for sp like; large event chains for historical post war set ups in Europe and soon Asia, loads of improvements to existing content & loc, improvements & expanded mechanics for Manchuquo & Japan, etc.

Lastly, what you describe seems to be mostly the impact of NSB on many aspects of the game, both for the players and perhaps even more for a modding team. We have been working on improving/restoring balance, sometimes in ways that don't work perfectly or everybody likes.
Things like eg the Allied Fleet entering the Baltic should have been fixed now and the removal of the free Wehrmacht/Luftwaffe foci has been made up for better NFs in the FT. Removing this was to get consistency as Germany was the only tag to receive such a free bonus.

Hope this clarifies a bit. Feel free to post feedback on the Discord, as there we can be may more responsive!
richfed 17 Sep, 2022 @ 1:35pm 
Just have to add a few things: Right now, Germany is largely unplayable in single player. Two BIG things -

1 - On purpose, the Reichskommissariats have been disabled (unless you are NOT at war). That is crazy, they were formed BECAUSE Germany was at war. Disabling them in this manner makes no sense to me. In effect, they are removed. Once war starts, Germany is never at peace until they are defeated

2 - Not on purpose (I hope), Germany can no longer send volunteers to Nationalist Spain during the Spanish Civil War.

Those are two very major obstacles for a German player.

Add to that, many generals have had their stats lowered, number of traits lowered, and von Leeb is gone completely unless you choose a specific national focus - and doing that prevents you from following a historical doctrine path because you can't get tank-radio.

I have tinkered with using the ModifyGUI mod [which allows you to adjust many things]. Boosting building and research speed by as much as 70% and I still cannot keep up with historical researches. I'm trying to adjust the settings to the point where I can make up for the things I have mentioned. [lost factories, resources, XPs, etc.] It requires quite a bit of boosting various things, but I still cannot get the proper "feel".

Germany should be "special." They dominated the war completely until the failed drive on Moscow.
< >
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
Per page: 1530 50