Alle discussies > Steam-forum > Off Topic > Details van topic
Shadow-79 4 jul om 19:13
Would a US remake of Squid Game really beat the original one or not?
Let's say they remade the entire series but with the cast consisting of Westerners and they're speaking English (the original one takes place in South Korea with a Korean cast with subtitles), but the thing is that the actual "Squid Game" is a Korean children's game which is not something that resonates with US culture, so would an actual American remake really succeed or fail?
Laatst bewerkt door Shadow-79; 4 jul om 19:16
< >
1-10 van 10 reacties weergegeven
Mad Scientist 4 jul om 19:38 
Depends on how good the writing is. If they keep the front man from the original that'd be great too.
#1
yankees992007 4 jul om 20:55 
It would fail miserably. One cannot discount cultural storylines surrounding Korea. Korea and United States differ vastly in cultural, societal and mannerism. Clothings and props would have to be changed to fit American styles. It would simply won't work without redoing everything in a different setting.
Laatst bewerkt door yankees992007; 4 jul om 21:02
#2
skOsH♥ 4 jul om 22:06 
I imagine it would be like this

https://youtube.com/watch?v=PzhR81bV0N0
#3
=(^ ^)= 4 jul om 22:09 
Name me one time an usa remake was better than the original.
#4
baconborn 4 jul om 22:10 
There's already Hunger Games and The Purge which are kinda similar concepts.
#5
St✩rlight 4 jul om 22:11 
It might be successful I mean there must have been a market for the American version of The Ring.
#6
BunnieBealla 4 jul om 22:12 
I still can't get over how they were playing a Korean game in ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ L.A. lmfao uwu
#7
Tröjan 4 jul om 22:56 
Plz no!
#8
salamander 4 jul om 22:58 
probably will be bad, but apparently the spanish version of breaking bad is pretty good, so who knows? give it a chance i guess
#9
yankees992007 4 jul om 23:03 
Origineel geplaatst door skOsH♥:
I imagine it would be like this

https://youtube.com/watch?v=PzhR81bV0N0

Good point. If that a preview of what a remake looks like, very bad idea.
#10
< >
1-10 van 10 reacties weergegeven
Per pagina: 1530 50

Alle discussies > Steam-forum > Off Topic > Details van topic
Geplaatst op: 4 jul om 19:13
Aantal berichten: 10
Een nieuwe discussie starten

Regels en richtlijnen voor discussies