I think the Buff Buffer is fine as it is, but I am not going to participate in this buff discussion anymore

Originally posted by Thrynity:

So you would like the buff buffer only support ?
As played as a medic ? XD
nah for real, the buff buffer can be used for offensive
Taking a pick axe, increase melee damage with my Rocket
getting my mini-crit and kill them all
that's what I do with the buff buffer

Nah, for real, when i join a serv and I see, a heavy or some medic
I grab the buff buffer for duplicate it
or in Stop that tank, because it's easy to build rage on tank

I just think, Increase a bit the rage build rate would be good

I replied to Mason.S's Buff Banner change suggestion, which, as mentioned in the very own post you quoted, would encourage soldiers to sit behind corners while their teammates did all of the work.

Originally posted by Mason.S:

adding a damage vulnerability

That sounds pretty decent, altough I think the current drawback is better, as much I hate it

Originally posted by Mason.S:

while using the buff as well? (For the Soldier, at least.)

no

you underestimate the power of the buff

when the buff rings, it is too late

the ability to give a speed / minicrits / defense boost is very, very strong, especially if it is for 30 seconds and within a radius of 662.5 HU

you might excuse it with the fact that soldier is able to die much quicker while under the effects of a buff, but the 'no buff effect' and 'increased damage' penalties encourage soldiers to hide behind corners, which regardless makes the entire performance of the rest of the team much, much better, whatever you would say

a single soldier not being buffed wouldn't make that big of a difference

an entire team does.

tl;dr: no.

The Duke and Stab n Away are so weak they make me cry

I suggest to add 1.5 seconds extra duration of all of the kill effects and 50% increased accuracy to the Duke

For the Stab n Away, decrease the extra decloak time to 0.9 seconds

Originally posted by Jregorian Kriskoff ツ:

Support Wrench REWORKED
(+) All teammates receive constant healing and ammo
(-) Wait what? There's a sentry now as well? What's the downside?

Buff Buffer REWORKED
(+) Buff Buff Buff
(-) You know those guys who try to help their teammates, which are basically every banner user ever? they get no downside

no

Originally posted by A Guy:

(+) Allows you to disable enemy primaries, helping your team out

There were so many things which you could have done to help your team

Yet you decided to equip the American Gothic

Originally posted by Crafting | cTF2w:

3) added bleeding during both stages, along with the 10 damage

4) maybe add sound or text when infection starts

But isn't the point of the weapon to remain stealthy?
How about adding the bleed only during the second stage?

Originally posted by Jregory Krisk ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°):

The current Infection is OP and UP at the same time. All which this does is remove the OP.

Originally posted by Thrynity:

can't use % due to Stop that tank and freak fortress high health (you would instakill ff2 boss)

Oh yeah, I guess that makes sense

Originally posted by Thrynity:

The finish line should just be removed of ff2 servers, no need to nerf it

It is already removed

Originally posted by Thrynity:

2 second stun O_o, look at medic escape

Agreed, it is a bit too OP.

Originally posted by Thrynity:

Finish line only 1% ??? that suck

No. The boss(es) can get ridiculous amounts of health when the server has lots of players.

Originally posted by Thrynity:

Culling blade can't use % now

Uh, why?

Originally posted by Thrynity:

75 health is fine

Not sure to which stat you are refering to, so I won't say anything