Recent reviews by Mr. Mackey

Positives:

• A good continuation of the story from the base game
  
• New beasts and mechanics are fun
  
• Personally I love Torvin as a character so missions and dialogue with him are a great

Negatives:

• I encountered quite a few bugs, a standout was after Caragarth stealth kills I would phase through and become trapped underground on my mount
  
• Some missions are frustrating either through controls or being overwhelmed with so many enemies ( I will never go near a Wretched Graug mission again, so poorly designed )
  
• Not a lot of added content and confined to 1 map (unlike the main story where there are 2)

If you like Torvin and beat master quests or just want more from Shadow of Mordor it's worth a play. but I recommend getting this dlc bundled or on sale.

Just buy all your competitors

Pros:
- Fun and unique puzzles
- Standard beat em up combat
- Interesting story

Cons:
- Very buggy
- Being knocked down often takes a large amount of time (10 seconds+) to get up again
- Runbacks are long and boring in some areas of the game

Not the best PC port but playable

Soldier of Godrick too hard

Beat the game first try (1 death after 2 seconds for not configuring mic properly). Don't know if it's just me but the game got less scary the more i played it and I saw a lot of jumpscares being reused. Massive potential, might change my review after updates.

A genuinely fun (and sometimes annoying) little game you can waste some time with. There's a lot of satisfaction when reaching a new record after so many failed attempts.

Train

RIP