I've gone through all the edit packs now and they're all clearly fictional except these ones in edit pack 2. The fictional edits in the other packs are obvious because they're brightly coloured and have anime heads and weird stuff like this. They also usually use 150 edit points exactly.

The edits in edit pack 2 also all use 150 edit points except for Randy Couture and I think Mark Coleman who each use 190 points. So Akira Shoji, Steve Wright, Barry Windham(?), some mystery Japanese guy, Wolf from Virtua Fighter, Valentijn Overeem, Vanderlei Da Silva, and some mystery video game character all use 150 points.

The other real edits in the Spike packs have different number of edit points used, depending on the character. It's not an even number like 150 all the time.

So these edits from edit pack 2 are clearly based on real people but they used this weird 150 point system that they also used for the fictional edits. It's a bit disappointing.

Yeah, I looked at some of those "fictional?" wrestlers years ago and they clearly looked fictional. But I'm going to look again.

Awesome! This makes me wonder how many of the edits I've seen listed as 'Fictional?' may actually be real wrestlers.