The mod probably needs to be updated, a lot of the abilities I've experimented with didn't take effect. For example, no cultural values are gained from looting, and no Great General points are gained from unit promotions

Tested and the manual update for GS still works as of May 2024. Opened a discussion with the code changes to make the Comanche playable in any ruleset so the change doesn't get lost in the comments.

@nitzer Are you sure you were using the GS ruleset? That older change won't show the Comanche if you select Standard or R&F rulesets.

Sadly after latest updates this mod stopped working even if you change 'Players:Expansion1_Players' to 'Players:Expansion2_Players' So bye bye for now Comanche :(

This mod is great, hopefully it can be updated for gathering storm

Unfortunately, this lovely mod doesn't work with GS. The others work, but this one doesn't.
it might be a good idea to update it.

@nitzer how to i get it to work help pls

They doesn't appear in selection.

Changing all the 'Players:Expansion1_Players' to 'Players:Expansion2_Players' in the ComancheConfig.sql file got it working with GS for me.

the navajo and cheyenne civ worked for me but this one just doesn't show up when i want to select it @nitzer

i think it sadly doesn't work anymore

@Ciar Aon your advice is great !! Now it works for F&F+GS+NF. Thanks Mate !! A beer from me :)

A wonderful mod. A very interesting nation to play with. There is only one nuance. It requires an update so that you can play using it in the latest version of the game.

Some of the civ abilities don't seem to be working in New Frontier, Great Raid in particular :(

Who did the Civ Icon? It looks amazing, and I want to ask the artist about the symbology.

@Ramon, Same

Needs to be upgraded to GS + New Frontier. It is not displayed in the selection of civilizations.

Does this work with the GS version of the city style pack or would I have to dive into a file to make that happen? Loving the aesthetic, just wondering if I can use this or not.

The TSL support for ynamp (GEM) is not working unfortunately... they just don't show up in advanced settings, when the option "only TSL" is checked. In the mod support file for GEM the TSL 15/70 is given, but unfortunately this is Brussels, anyway... one would expect rather something like 141/61 (Oklahoma). @EnigmaConundrum maybe you can take a look and "repair" the TSL support

@Ciar Ago, omg, for me the same... couldn't believe it but works now

TSP support for ynamp plz

Changing all the 'Players:Expansion1_Players' to 'Players:Expansion2_Players' in the ComancheConfig.sql file got it working with GS for me.

does not work

Great addition--love the production quality. I have one question though: what's the symbolism behind the Civ Icon? Considering the ability names, I tried googling 'Comanche Moon', but got nothing.

Some insight into the history behind it/links to images & info elsewhere would be greatly appreciated!

BASED

any reason why settlers dont show up for game start? Rise & Fall rule set

I can see it in the civilopedia but it doesn't show up in the civ-selection screen

hi can you upgrade this mod because it causes bugs in the game

Yeah :D

Hello there! So, my life has been, shall we say, hectic for the past few months. So much so that I've all but had to drop Civ (and yes, it's sucked) to keep up with school, college apps, etc. However, Coronacation has given me a lot of time to get shit back in order, and I'll probably have time to fix all of these broken civs now. I can't say exactly when they'll all be ready, as I have to diagnose the problems and do updates on quite a few mods, but expect stuff soon - and maybe with a couple of improvements here or there ;)

Hey, there is currently an issue with the civs abilities in that they dont work at all. Took a look at the logs and saw these errors:
Runtime Error: E:\SteamLibrary\steamapps\workshop\content\289070\1213433695\lua\ComancheUIFunctions.lua:40: attempt to index a nil value
stack traceback:
E:\SteamLibrary\steamapps\workshop\content\289070\1213433695\lua\ComancheUIFunctions.lua:40: in function '(main chunk)'
[C]: in function '(anonymous)'
Thought i would report the issue, cheers man.

Leaders do not show up in game setup when using Gathering Storm expansion, but DO show up when using Rise and Fall. Will you be updating this to support Gathering Storm?

Can't select the leaders in game setup.

Am Sad

@birdnerd14 I have the same issue

For some reason every time i click "subscribe" the leaders don't show up in my leader selection thing when i create a game. Does anyone know why and/or how to fix this?

Any chance this can be updated for GS? This sounds like a super fun cub to play!

Quindorrian is absolutely right. I second that.

Dude... Your update broke my save game... OMG... Please help... Can you support an old version of the mod? It auto-updated and broke my saves and now I cannot load any of them...

The current Giant Earth TSL is placing them in Belgium rather than their proper location.

I get a kick back to menu when trying to start a game with this mod. It works when i disable it, it doesn't when it's enabled - so it must be this one.

I'm not sure if this matters or not but I'm on Linux, and I do have other mods enabled. I'm also missing some of the civ/scenario DLCs but I do have the R&F expansion.

The game currently fails to load with this mod enabled, even with no other active mods. All of your other mods seem to work just fine.

Thanks alot but is there any way to make this compatible with the ynamp true starting location mod. Thank you.

The bug which caused the civilization not to load in has been squashed

ON true start location it spawns in between france and the netherlands

Not shown in the leader choose, with All leader mod. R&f or mod incompability ?

I'm gonna second the request for a Sioux Nation civ after the issue with the Commanche civ is resolved. I live in the heart of Sioux country and would love to see my neighbors tribe represented as a civ in the game. Maybe with a Crazy Horse Monument Wonder (seeing as how the real one in South Dakota probably won't be completed in my lifetime)

E. Conundrum, I'm having that same problem. It only started recently, I had it loaded after R&F came out and it worked fine, now it doesn't show up. I subscribe to other mods of yours with no issue. Still waiting for a Sioux nation, maybe with Sitting Bull as leader and a Crazy Horse UU <wink, wink>!!! Pleeeeeeease! You don't need to work, come on.

Thank you.

I'm trying to work through the issue but I haven't had much time to, I'll make sure to mention as soon as this is up to date.

Same thing as Zombie Java Joe