I like how shiny it is but I think there's a faint seam (its easier to spot in the gifs)

we're making it INTO the hood with dis one!!

I thought this was a flat solid color background until I saw the promos again and noticed really subtle shimmering effect.

Very nice colors. Would use this war paint.

Very nice! :)

That brown is a little plain, try gold maybe?

shit

Phong mask carries this so hard
Could use a third texture

If this gets added the community sparkle effect will add a lot of depth to it

@carlos_hernandez2014 We don't even know if it's a stock image (it 99.99% probably isn't) since these star patterns can easily be made in photoshop or whatever art program. Not everything is a stock image. I wish people would stop jumping the stock image-accusation bandwagon.

I like this.
I want to see it in the game.

Definitely feels more like christmas than halloween, but it still looks pretty good. It is a sticker warpaint, so I get carlos' complaint about it seeming lazy, although the texturing still looks nice and it's pretty clear this has effort put into it to make it fit into the game while looking quite nice; the colors and texturing look fitting, the designs for the stars are interesting, and it's not too visually noisy despite some of the stars being small.
If anything I'd say it would've looked nicer if you'd been lazier and just used a base where you could use one of the sparkles as a sticker, but this looks decent as well and gives off a really nice christmas sweater feeling without looking ugly like many other sweater designs do.

this feels a bit more smissmas-y than halloween-y, but it's also tagged for it so it doesnt matter
looks cool!

1.) looks quite lazily made
2.) doesnt fit in tf2 at all
3.) kinda looks like stock images plastered on a basic team colored background