The hat itself is very nice - but being wholly paintable is a big nope. Wasted opportunity here to up the ante by making only the band paintable.

The whiskers are an interesting idea but will almost always fail on the pyro... These would be located at the top of his nose! Ew! The mask encompasses the nose and the mouth - exactly the region where such hair would have to go to.

TL;DR: Drop the whiskers and make only the band of the hat paintable isntead of the whole hat and you'll have a nice, clean and sophisticated item.

dont listen to other people this is an awesome hat I absolutely love it keep killing it I would buy one of these up if it ever got added

This doesn't really fit the game. It would work much better on any other class.

Pyro looks like he could go for some "crumpets and tea" right about now

These days you don't see enough cosmetics that are silly but tasteful.

fantastic!

While this retreads the same ground as the Whiskered Gentleman, I'll be honest: that old cosmetic never looked good to me. Its bright tape is just too distracting, making the black moustache blend even more into the mask.

Ever since I was first disappointed by it, I've wanted a better option. And while I feel this cosmetic's moustache could stand to be a bit bigger, it's still decidedly a step up compared to what we currently have.

"Let's make the Sophisticated Smoker multi-class and not tell Pyro"
And then the Pyro killed them, wore it, and made it their own cosmetic out of spite
Jokes aside, it's pretty solid, even if the mustache is a bit strange

Also, very nice item! Im upvoting!

The gentle pyro, this one probably says:
"hello madame, may I could with all my gentle burn you?"