Command: Modern Air / Naval Operations WOTY

Command: Modern Air / Naval Operations WOTY

US Naval Air Power Debate: F-35, 2016
24 Comments
AN/PVQ-31A 4 Jun, 2019 @ 9:42pm 
A couple of these options are sort of strawmen, as the people proposing to cut costs by lowering the number of supercarriers are usually not pro-F35 either, but generally anti and trying to make what they view as a bad situation better, since they do acknowledge the leap from harrier to supercruising stealth jet.

This is a more representative debate for Britain in my opinion, which really did debate using CTOL carriers, STOVL (which they went with) as well as possibly using Super Hornets, navalized Eurofighters, or F-35Cs or F-35Bs on the various ship designs. This included Super Hornets on ramp carriers.
Kazansky 26 Jan, 2018 @ 5:07pm 
Hi Baloogan, can you make a verion of this where the enemy aircraft are future Russian and Future Chinese aircraft, like PAK-FA and J-20/J-31 and add the Navalized F-22 to the US side just to see if the F-35 is still effective or if that Navalized F-22 was really a good idea.
Fredy 19 May, 2016 @ 10:42pm 
Archangel is right about you overplaying the cost of the F-35. The Super Hornet is actually quite expensive. Once factoring in the lifetime extention (Super Hornet is built for only 20 years), the F-35C become about the same when comparing FRP.

Send your F-35 questions to r/F35lightning if you want information regarding the F-35.
GiJoe41 30 Apr, 2016 @ 5:54pm 
It seems impossible to save the Ospreys in the beggining, they usually end up blundering first into the enemy SAG and then into a BUK, however what kills them most of the time ends up being the waves of fighters. I usually start out by sending the F-35Bs with SDB-IIs to kill the ships, 3 flights, each targeting one ship with it's bombs, then sending out tomohawks as sacrificial lambs to waste their missiles. The F-35s usually only suceed in killing one or two ships, but then i'm stuck up shit creek without a paddle as the BUK and the waves of J-10s and SU-XXs kill the last of the Ospreys, even with a hefty escort.
TitanLegion 15 Mar, 2016 @ 12:51pm 
Not to mention were not integrating storm shadow(250km) on our very limited range f35b. We need range!
TitanLegion 15 Mar, 2016 @ 12:49pm 
There is another option currently being debated in congress which is f35c/s.hornet/long range drone airwing. See Centre for New American security report by Jerry Hendrix. Aimed at countering Chinese ASBM. Hopefully all western modern navies will adopt these new airwings & keep the airframe air miles of our stealth planes for other purposes than being used up in low threat regions. I certainly hope the UK MOD adopts this for QE2. Cheers.
GasyKaManja exPS4Legend 10 Mar, 2016 @ 10:52am 
nice
Ace 9 Mar, 2016 @ 6:25pm 
Boa
Mishanya3838 8 Mar, 2016 @ 10:02pm 
Good)))
TAnC 8 Mar, 2016 @ 2:56pm 
good
Fabs63 8 Mar, 2016 @ 1:55pm 
good
Morally-Neutral Vore 8 Mar, 2016 @ 1:54pm 
Not realistic. The F-35s in the scenario can fly.
FlyingBull 8 Mar, 2016 @ 1:15pm 
good
vody na vody 8 Mar, 2016 @ 12:35pm 
good
:steamhappy:
SouSteal 8 Mar, 2016 @ 11:34am 
good
Kitsu♥ 8 Mar, 2016 @ 10:22am 
Good
underrated 8 Mar, 2016 @ 10:18am 
Looks good
加了个七 8 Mar, 2016 @ 4:56am 
GOOD
遇到新东方厨师就嫁了 8 Mar, 2016 @ 12:44am 
.......
mb 7 Mar, 2016 @ 7:57pm 
。。。
Inferno Dragon 7 Mar, 2016 @ 11:22am 
+rep

Special Snowflake 6 Mar, 2016 @ 6:33pm 
k
Garythewhale 5 Mar, 2016 @ 6:28pm 
how do you put aircraft on an aircraft carrier in the editor ?
Loxachi 1 Mar, 2016 @ 10:17pm 
Well over all a good mission the premise that the F-35C cost more relative to the SH at least when looking at over all procurment numbers over time is untrue. Now if your comparing it to the F-18C, the aircraft its meant to replace, you have a point but the difference in capability there is nothing short of staggering. In reality if the F-35 was as expensive as you play it out to be its likley the USN would have procured more and updated/ SLEP'd many of its F-18Cs in contrast to buying more F-18E/F/G. Also as it stands I believe that the number of total available F-35s (IE those that are not in depo and actually deployable) will be higher than that of the F-18s. As aside If we are looking at a mission involving large numbers of F-35Cs I would have set the scenario for 2022 or later.