Warframe

Warframe

Excalibur - Pretech v.1.1
Jivy 2 Feb, 2018 @ 1:13am
lore freindly?
i feel like it kinda isnt lore freindly cause of the helmet looking like it can be removed but thats just my opinion
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Jeffman12 2 Feb, 2018 @ 9:21am 
Well, there's more than that going on here, like the 'straps' and the robo-abs. It's lacking a subtlety I've come to expect from the bio-tech warframes.
Crew 2 Feb, 2018 @ 9:41am 
Wait skins have to be lore friendly? Thats not a requirement, and if it is, its extremely lenient considering already existing skins.
JaK'Mar [MJ] 2 Feb, 2018 @ 10:09am 
If it would more match to the Corpus, then I would vote for "Yes", but it caused me to vote for the opposite.
Last edited by JaK'Mar [MJ]; 2 Feb, 2018 @ 10:09am
пек 2 Feb, 2018 @ 2:27pm 
I just feel like it doesn't fit into the game.
00Chicken00 2 Feb, 2018 @ 4:13pm 
I ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ LOVE IT it looks like corpus but the color from the grineer TAKE MY MONY
Hazuki-chan 2 Feb, 2018 @ 8:12pm 
There are actually style guidelines for these things; for instance, skins can be themed around Corpus, Grineer, Tenno or Infested stylings, with each having different guidelines, but I believe abstraction of the face (i.e. no eyes or mouth where you'd expect them) is a fairly big one. Granted, the rules get bent or barely scraped by here and there, from what I've seen, and I honestly don't know if an opaque yet familiarly-shaped helmet face would count as abstracted or not.

Overall, I would guess they'd judge this too contemporary or something like that; design sensibilities have changed between present day, near future, and the point in time where Warframe takes place. Although certain retro-styled skins have been accepted, these still tend to be rather more elaborate and fanciful.

That's all just my two cents, though; you can check out the style guidelines for yourself somewhere on the official site, I believe.^^
Azrael 2 Feb, 2018 @ 9:30pm 
@Hazukichan:
Exactly my opinion.

It is not a bad job, design-wise, but I feel it is very inconsistent with the warframe basics.
Not meta-organic enough, if you catch my drift here.

It just looks like it belongs into annother sci-fi realm, with a different style of tech.

Just my two cents.



Edit:
I just realized, it looks extremely similar to my Champions: Online mech-themed hero, back in the day. Just too similar to be comfortable to be in WF.
Last edited by Azrael; 2 Feb, 2018 @ 9:33pm
Einherjar 2 Feb, 2018 @ 11:16pm 
Originally posted by ᴘʀɪsᴄɪʟʟᴏɴ:
Originally posted by Jivy The Wolf:
i feel like it kinda isnt lore freindly cause of the helmet looking like it can be removed but thats just my opinion

Doesn't need to be lore-friendly. Take a look at some skins accepted in the game , I don't think that dragons are in the game's lore. :D

Um actually there's a Dragon themed Warframe....
Roaring Dragon 3 Feb, 2018 @ 12:47am 
Originally posted by ᴘʀɪsᴄɪʟʟᴏɴ:
Originally posted by Jivy The Wolf:
i feel like it kinda isnt lore freindly cause of the helmet looking like it can be removed but thats just my opinion

Doesn't need to be lore-friendly. Take a look at some skins accepted in the game , I don't think that dragons are in the game's lore. :D
There is even a title named dragon, so I kindof feel that dragons are lore-friendly
Last edited by Roaring Dragon; 3 Feb, 2018 @ 12:47am
Kitteh 3 Feb, 2018 @ 9:46am 
This is actually lore freindly, there was a game already made by DE called dark sector, the precursour to warframe and it featured tech just like this and even the name of the Tenno comes from the name of the main charcter "James Tenno". who became the first ever warframe (excalibur) so it could be included!
Jeffman12 3 Feb, 2018 @ 9:56am 
Originally posted by ᴘʀɪsᴄɪʟʟᴏɴ:
I don't think that dragons are in the game's lore. :D

Chroma.

Also, dragons don't need to exist for one to make something that looks "dragonly"
They're a concept, a part of human mythology, and therefore a part of our history, no matter how obscure they may seem in the time of Warframe, and clearly, due to Chroma, it's not too obscure for the Tenno to dream up.

This skin on the other hand doesn't look like anything else in game except maybe a couple tennogen syandanas. I'm not going to vote for it, and since I only play with people I know, I probably won't be seeing it around even if it does come through.

Not to say this isn't well made, but it just feels too blunt and lacking nuance for what I've come to expect from the game.
Last edited by Jeffman12; 3 Feb, 2018 @ 10:02am
Roaring Dragon 3 Feb, 2018 @ 10:23am 
Originally posted by Jeffman12:
This skin on the other hand doesn't look like anything else in game except maybe a couple tennogen syandanas. I'm not going to vote for it, and since I only play with people I know, I probably won't be seeing it around even if it does come through.
Well as many of us state in one of the other discussions around this skin it looks like Vauban a bit, so to say that it doesnt look like anything in the game isnt entirely true.
Roaring Dragon 3 Feb, 2018 @ 10:28am 
Originally posted by Kitteh:
This is actually lore freindly, there was a game already made by DE called dark sector, the precursour to warframe and it featured tech just like this and even the name of the Tenno comes from the name of the main charcter "James Tenno". who became the first ever warframe (excalibur) so it could be included!
Well I didnt even know about this game, but your right. As I looked into the game I realised many things was the same like for example the glaive, and they even have a skin reference already in warframe. I however cant find exactly what this is in that game (but again I previously didnt know of it at all).
Hazuki-chan 3 Feb, 2018 @ 10:41am 
Originally posted by Kitteh:
This is actually lore freindly, there was a game already made by DE called dark sector, the precursour to warframe and it featured tech just like this and even the name of the Tenno comes from the name of the main charcter "James Tenno". who became the first ever warframe (excalibur) so it could be included!
I thought it was Hayden Tenno? At least, that is what I've read people deciphered from the Orokin script on the side of Excalibur's helmet. Also, there is some ambiguity on the matter, but I believe DE themselves have stated the games are not set in exactly the same universe... similar ones, perhaps, but my own personal guess is that they don't want to worry about people saying "This doesn't make sense given what we saw in Dark Sector" when they add some new content or backstory to Warframe.

If we extrapolate a bit from that and go "Well, it seems probable that a period with design sensibilities similar to those seen in Dark Sector may still have occurred somewhere in the rear view mirror of Warframe's own timeline", then perhaps this skin could make sense as a nod to the people and ideas of bygone times, just as the Nikana reminds us of a katana from feudal-era japan and countless other weapons have their own obvious or obscure inspirations in pre-space-flight human history.

The more I think about it, the less sure I am, one way or the other.
Count Spartula 3 Feb, 2018 @ 12:21pm 
It really doesn't fit the game's styles.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Per page: 1530 50