Is the chance of getting a Reflected pickup/item by default really only 0.6%? It feels *much* higher than that, I've gotten Reflected items at least once per run pretty consistently, and I usually get 11 or 12 Reflected pickups per run, sometimes I get 3 or 4 in the same room! I should logically only be encountering them once per run if even, that's lower than a 1 in 100 chance.

IMO, the chance should be a flat 1% for both items and Pickups, *maybe* 0.5% for Items if that's too common. 1 in 100 means you'll probably see 1 or 2 reflected pickups per run, which keeps them present and allows the tradeoff decision to be made fairly commonly without them saturating the drops too much. Also, I feel like Reflected Items should cost more to take, potentially double damage (so a full heart/two full hearts in C4+)? Getting a duplicate of an item could potentially be run-changing.

(Also, Reflected coins can drop when Tainted Keeper kills an enemy, which probably shouldn't be able to happen because they're completely free if you're not injured, but if you are injured it robs you of healing and potentially gets you killed if you don't realize in time)

The chance should be 2/300 (~0.66%) and this chance increases to 6/300 (2%) when you break the mirror in downpour/dross. So i might have to look into why you're encountering them so commonly (plus i might increase it a little like you suggested)...

As for the taking of more health i'll think about it. Perhaps only in womb and floors beyond that.

And i'll try to disable reflection spawns for coins dropped by Tainted Keeper. And i'll do the same for hearts dropped my Tainted Maggy. Because i 100% agree with you that this happening is just ass

A bunch of various ideas I had

Rotten Poop - New Poop Type - On destruction it works like rainbow poop but fills all containers and replaces all red hearts with Rotten Hearts

Calcified Poop - New Poop Type - Has a chance to replace red poop and has a chance to drop bone hearts

Runny Poop - New Poop Type - On destruction creates creep (only damages enemies)

Bloody Poop - New Poop Type - Chance to replace red poop, same as Runny Poop but this creep also damages isaac

(Unsure on the Dip variants for these)

Laxatives - Trinket - Whilst held there a higher chance for poop to be replaced with special poops

Toilet Paper - Passive Item - Chance for poop to replace rocks, on destroying poop gain a small stats up depending on the poop type (temporary boost on common poops but special ones give permanent stat ups)

Bottoms Up - New Pill - For this floor isaac is under the effects of Rock Bottom

Abusive Relationship - Passive Item - Excess red hearts can be picked up and are instead turned into damage ups

Twinstincts - Passive Item - If no familiars exist on isaac is also given a random familiar item, Isaac has a chance to also fire the same tears as his familiars.

Whirling leech appears in the boss pool. It appeared in the mirror dimension boss drop.
Is this intended?

Originally posted by Quetzalcóatl:

Whirling leech appears in the boss pool. It appeared in the mirror dimension boss drop.
Is this intended?

For now it is (reason being is that it's a health up) but i might change this later on

oh I think the EID description didn't mention that it was a health up
maybe that was the issue

Originally posted by Quetzalcóatl:

oh I think the EID description didn't mention that it was a health up
maybe that was the issue

Whoops you're right! I'll update the description

configs for your collection mods to turn off specific items?

Originally posted by Badsy the Edgecat:

configs for your collection mods to turn off specific items?

Not / barely possible via the current modding API

Whirling leech still doesn't have the updated description in EID or in encyclopedia to add that hp up part

Originally posted by Quetzalcóatl:

Whirling leech still doesn't have the updated description in EID or in encyclopedia to add that hp up part

Whoops i added it a while ago but ended up accidentally overwriting it later on . It should be added in the newest version (for real this time)

i dont think plastic bag should be in the boss room pool since boss room items give 3 things
1. hp ups
2. stats up
3. drop pickups/trinkets/held items
(cube of meat/ball of bandages is an exception, if pills can give you pretty fly than weak orbitals work as well)

also make the creep for it disappear after enough time, having stick around infinitely is pretty broken

Originally posted by An_Annoying_Cat:

i dont think plastic bag should be in the boss room pool since boss room items give 3 things
1. hp ups
2. stats up
3. drop pickups/trinkets/held items
(cube of meat/ball of bandages is an exception, if pills can give you pretty fly than weak orbitals work as well)

also make the creep for it disappear after enough time, having stick around infinitely is pretty broken

I've removed the item from the Greed boss pool

As for balancing the item. I don't want the creep to disappear since vanilla poop creep also doesn't disappear and i want the item's effect to remain consistent with the base game. However, I've slightly bumped the chance for butt bombs to be spawned to try and make the item a little more balanced.

And i may just bump up the item's quality in the future!

haunted rose needs to be nerfed. the ghosts it spawns are too strong and last forever, they should explode like regular ghost bomb ones, and it also shouldnt show up in greed mode

Originally posted by Badsy the Edgecat:

haunted rose needs to be nerfed. the ghosts it spawns are too strong and last forever, they should explode like regular ghost bomb ones, and it also shouldnt show up in greed mode

I mean you're trading health for them so it seems more than fine. And they behave exactly the same as ghosts spawned by ghost bombs (including their disappearing speed and damage scaling)