So, i just finished the campaign,.....i absolutely agree with the sentiment of the rest of the players....it is one of the best SP campaigns for Arma 3, actually more enjoyable than the vanilla campaign storywise. And, 95% of the voice acting is really, really good. And that is something most community made missions and campaigns fail. I applaude you!

Some feedback; i played with no mods. I usually have access to the VA at all times, but actually trying to get things done realistically with what you found was quite fun. Really made you feel like you had to be really smart and Guerilla like on what and when to attack.

So, in the first proper fighting mission, Point of No Return, i feel it is kinda unrealistic that you are left alone to go into the compound, clear that out and place the explosives while your team leaves for the rally point already. If they really wanted to succedd, would they not go in with 2-3 people and leave one-two standing guard or overwatch? You have to go in alone and take out at least 2 aaf infantry, jeopardizing the goal of placing the explosives.

The cutscene afterwards, Decisions, really is one of or the best cinematic in Arma 3 i have ever seen. Can't even remeber the last movie that captured the futility, distress and overpowering agony of war so well like these couple of minutes. Kudos to that one!

Weeks later indeed was a bit long or too much in one ride. You really have to be smart with your pcmls. Additionally, if a mission has so many quests or objectives, you likely end up running into that typical role playling game problem where you have to suspend believe and do sidequests although the main quest is of way higher importance. But thats really just a minor issue.

During the Contact mission, i kinda felt it a bit unrealistic that Pavlos really would go and deal with the generator problem and promising instead to do it the following days and forcefully asking for the keys to rescue his men if need be. Yes, the intention of helping surely is to build networks and support for the cause with the altian people. Still, i think it would highlight the unpleasantness of civil war even more if Pavlos had to make hard choices, like even hurting locals to achieve his goals. Civil war seems to be a very messy business, and the story would be even more powerful if Pavlos and his men were not able to remain on the 'just side of history' so easily. In the end they are killing a lot of altian soldiers already,....presumeably former commrads with families of their own. I believe morally and practically it wouldn't be easy if you were an active member of an army that stands to make a choice whether to leave the service (if thats even an option legal/contractwise) or stay during an unfolding civil war.

On my way back to the island in the dinghy, i ran into a bug after the team was regrouped and team switch was activated. They wouldn't follow my orders and move to the boat. I could order them to chance stance etc. but they were all stuck and wouldn't walk anywhere. I had to take control over each one individually and walk them down to the boat. Worked out fine though.

The last mission, The Picture,....thats one of those arma missions i hate the most. The cutscenes leading up to it are fantastic and i get what you were trying to achieve. That mission really makes you wanne play chapter two and three for sure. But once you have to flee the Photoshoot at the crossroad,....arma being arma means this is just an exercise in frustration. Trying to drive and run out of there without being insta-shot, reloading this 5-10 times is just not fun. But i managed to get out of there with the car intact and that was that.

Overall, again, one of the best campaings for Arma 3. The civilian side of modern warfare is totally underplayed in arma 3 and you achieved to bring this actually alive as best as can be expected withing the confines of the game. I know you hae stated to not go back to making chapter 2 and 3 happen (yeah, years have passed). But if you did, i sure as hell would play them. Not just because they surely would flesh out the events prior to the East Wind, but i really want ot find out what sinister networks are at play and who that murderer you were supposed to ID in the last mission, and how all of this ties to the Dark Father and how those different groups are linked or opposed to CSAT.

May i ask, what is the main motivation killer for you to not finish the campaign? Just the tedious work of building the missions, or do you think you would not get the old voice actor gang together?

Anyway, you efforts are really appreciated and you have my gratitude for some of the most enjoyable hours in Arma 3 i have had! Cheers mate.