The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth

The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth

Full Pickup Prevention
138 Comments
󰀏Niko  [author] 14 Jun @ 7:46am 
Last I checked, there isn't a dynamic way to tell the difference between pickups and otherwise. I could maybe make a section in the menu that is automatically filled with every found object and the user could manually specify what each is, but that would be a bit complex for the average user.

Maybe I will look into that whenever I get back into working on this mod, but I have my doubts on that being any time soon.
mata 14 Jun @ 7:29am 
maybe, you could also add mod compatibility (e.g. trinket coins from reshaken mod)
󰀏Niko  [author] 14 Jun @ 6:34am 
I tried to make the config as convenient as possible.

I really should update this mod again...
󰀏Niko  [author] 14 Jun @ 6:33am 
With the config you can always temporarily make the mod effectively non-existent mid-run if you ever need.
mata 14 Jun @ 5:36am 
not ideal for specific min/max situations (like D1-ing chests)

all in all, works on rep+
♥ Astrid ♥ 17 Dec, 2024 @ 11:04am 
this mod is broken for rep+ for me
theadods 27 Aug, 2024 @ 4:42am 
it's the same, but there's no menu for this mod in the left panel, is there any file i can change to manually edit the settings?
󰀏Niko  [author] 26 Aug, 2024 @ 10:28am 
That's strange, it seems to be working for me. Double check if the MCM mod you have is the same one I have linked in the description, and if you have a different one, try that one and see if the problem persists.
theadods 26 Aug, 2024 @ 1:06am 
I'm using Mod Config Menu Pure, but the config for this mod doesn't appear, any other way to change the setting?
󰀏Niko  [author] 11 May, 2024 @ 10:31pm 
Good idea!
firecoat13 11 May, 2024 @ 12:28pm 
you should add an option to push away specific pickups regardless of max cap, like I want an option where I can still pick up nickels and dimes but not pennies. Maybe you could do this by making the mod affects pickups menu not affected by push all and phase all?
aceofspace 28 Jan, 2024 @ 4:27pm 
all right thanks
󰀏Niko  [author] 28 Jan, 2024 @ 2:09pm 
Ah, right. I forgot about Tainted Cain, I'll add hearts to the list when I find time. In the meantime you can use the "Push All" or "Phase All" modes which will apply to absolutely everything.
aceofspace 28 Jan, 2024 @ 12:14pm 
in the pickups section of the config it'd be cool if it had a hearts category, if it's even possible to apply it to hearts.
aceofspace 28 Jan, 2024 @ 12:04pm 
not a huge deal but i've gotten pretty frustrated accidentally picking up soul hearts and losing good recipes as tainted cain.
aceofspace 28 Jan, 2024 @ 12:04pm 
i'd like to not be able to pickup hearts while playing tainted cain unless im holding the alt key.
󰀏Niko  [author] 28 Jan, 2024 @ 11:24am 
For the most part don't hearts work like that by default? Or am I missing something here? Could you give more details on what you want the hearts to behave compared to how they currently do?
aceofspace 27 Jan, 2024 @ 10:50pm 
like all hearts including soul hearts
aceofspace 27 Jan, 2024 @ 10:50pm 
can you make it work with hearts as well?
Damglador 21 Dec, 2023 @ 5:33pm 
Best modder ever
󰀏Niko  [author] 11 Sep, 2023 @ 8:20am 
@Dm0pt, huh, very strange... The latest update was made to specifically fix that issue and it's been working for me. The only possibilities I can think of is either you have some other mod that is overriding this mod's save data, or something is wrong with your save data preventing it from saving fully. Do other parts of the config save correctly or are they also broken?

Maybe try resetting the config and see if that magically fixes it?
Try disabling every mod except for MCM and FPP and see if it still breaks then.
millipede 11 Sep, 2023 @ 12:30am 
I use MCM pure, yet every time i exit to the main menu or restart a run the button changes from shift back to ctrl
󰀏Niko  [author] 10 Sep, 2023 @ 10:05am 
@Dm0pt, Changing the control in MCM should be saving every time it's changed for most MCM-like mods. What MCM mod do you use if any?

Personally I use "MCM -Pure" and it seems to save the controls and all other settings for me just fine. You can find an easy link to it anywhere in the description MCM is mentioned.
millipede 10 Sep, 2023 @ 12:11am 
Is there a way to permanently change the control for picking up items in my files instead of going into config every time? (I want to change it from CTRL to Shift)
󰀏Niko  [author] 7 Sep, 2023 @ 5:27pm 
MCM Pure finally works for me, so updates are back on the menu.

Support for MCM Pure has already been implemented in the latest update, but y'all let me know if there is anything else in need of fixing or if settings don't save correctly.
󰀏Niko  [author] 23 Aug, 2023 @ 8:28am 
Ah, good idea @DmOpt. I will add it to my list of plans and add it whenever I have the motivation to work on this mod again, however that may take a long while with life stuff getting in the way.

As a temporary fix you could set the mod to "Push All" or "Phase All" mode.
millipede 23 Aug, 2023 @ 3:51am 
can you make smart keeper but for tainted cain? just make it so cain cant pick up anything at all
icyi 26 Jul, 2023 @ 6:41am 
very epic for funny d20 greed moments
󰀏Niko  [author] 23 Jul, 2023 @ 3:12pm 
Sorry about that @CAROLING HELLWALKER, That's a known issue, Unlike MCM Continued, MCM Pure requires the mod to save the config manually which this mod was not made for. Lately I have been lacking motivation thus is why the mod has not been updated in a long time. Though it doesn't help that no version of MCM has worked for me for a while now and I have not had the motivation to look into why that is, though I suspect it's due to a random mod I have.
Evil and intimidating moldspore 23 Jul, 2023 @ 11:51am 
Okay uh. Ever since mod config continued was discontinued this mod still works fine with mod pure, but for whatever reason it automatically resets the settings to default each time i start a new run. its been incredibly frustrating to retoggle the options I want to use. Is there any way to fix that because its been bugging me for ages
󰀏Niko  [author] 4 Jun, 2023 @ 8:01am 
Have you tried running only this mod?
Alcoholism drives in my family 4 Jun, 2023 @ 3:35am 
Cannot be, it worked perfectly before installing this one mod
󰀏Niko  [author] 3 Jun, 2023 @ 11:01am 
The hearts dropped from enemies are temporary items, this mod completely avoids touching temporary items. So you should always be able to pick up the dropped hearts, perhaps another mod you have is getting in the way?
Alcoholism drives in my family 3 Jun, 2023 @ 10:15am 
the mod completely ruins tmaggy, it doesnt let me pick up hearts dropped from enemies
原雨相打游戏很蔡qwq 20 Jan, 2023 @ 8:46pm 
注:忏悔里版本的深口袋将钱币上限改成了999,但是加上了这个mod还是只能拿起99硬币
󰀏Niko  [author] 13 Dec, 2022 @ 3:15am 
Sounds like the Andromeda mod has the effects happen when a pickup is touched rather then picked up. Seems like a mod incompatibility on their end.
ATi 12 Dec, 2022 @ 5:21pm 
I should also note, there's a bug with the Andromeda mod, where as playing as Tainted Andromeda.

Short summary of how the character works, picking up items such as coins, bombs or keys charge the meter on your ability, of which spawn an item. But the problem is that upon reaching the max amount of any pickup then trying to grab more will result your ability to charge anyway, basically giving you infinite items.
ATi 12 Dec, 2022 @ 5:14pm 
Should of read the description, thanks a lot.
󰀏Niko  [author] 12 Dec, 2022 @ 3:41pm 
That is indeed a feature of this mod, I call it "Smart Keeper", It's on by default but I am still on the fence about that. It prevents coin pickup unless you need it for healing. (Temporary coins can always be picked up)

Note: As with any part of this mod, you can hold the drop key to interact with things like normal, in addition if you have MCM you can turn the feature completely off or change what coins it will effect.

Sorry if this has caused a inconvenience. Hopefully I have cleared things up, do feel free to give feedback on the feature if it annoys you.
ATi 12 Dec, 2022 @ 12:17am 
Idk if its this mod, but I cant pick up coins as keeper at full health.
25kubalok 29 Oct, 2022 @ 3:11am 
thank you for answer!
󰀏Niko  [author] 28 Oct, 2022 @ 7:52pm 
Stikngne has brought to my attention that is an issue with "MCM Pure", for more information you can read the discussion post they made. I will look into supporting that version if and when I can find the time, but until then, I recommend using "MCM Continued" links to which can be found anywhere in the mod description where MCM is mentioned.
Feel free to let me know if this would be an issue for you and I'll make it a higher priority.
25kubalok 28 Oct, 2022 @ 4:50am 
When I'm turning off prevention from charged keys or golden bombs and golden keys it always resets on next run. I just can't save my settings in this mod for some reason. Other mods works without any problems with customizations, but this one always resets...
Videofreak 7 Oct, 2022 @ 4:53pm 
Wish I remembered about this on a greedier run with head of the keeper...
󰀏Niko  [author] 19 Sep, 2022 @ 1:00pm 
Yeah there are a few bugs related to doubled characters that share stuff that I need to work out. I just need to find a good way to tell if the given character shares with another or not.
Snaximus 19 Sep, 2022 @ 12:24pm 
Breaks for Tainted Forgotten, when Deep Pockets is picked up, The Soul cannot pick up coins but can throw The Body to collect them.
󰀏Niko  [author] 23 Aug, 2022 @ 3:15pm 
"Smart Keeper" effects both normal and tainted variants. Coins heal keeper and tainted keeper, "Smart Keeper" mode saves coins so you can come back to them to heal later. It's very helpful for people who like to min-max their runs which after all is the whole point of this mod in the first place. Remember that holding the drop key (configurable) allows for you to bypass any effects of the mod temporarily and that you can always turn smart keeper off entirely if you don't like it.

As for why it only effects you in the custom challenge I still have no clue, Smart Keeper mode should be working the same rather you are in a normal run playing as Normal/Tainted Keeper as it would in the challenge, I feel like there might be something more here than I am aware of with the challenge.


TL,DR: "Smart Keeper" mode is to aid with healing, if you don't like it there are multiple ways to bypass it's effects, either temporary or permanent.
Jalapeno 23 Aug, 2022 @ 1:25pm 
its t keeper, and it only does this in my custom challenge. also how is it intentional if i have 000 coins, why would anyone want that?
󰀏Niko  [author] 23 Aug, 2022 @ 10:14am 
Are you playing keeper? If so not picking up coins is intentional, if you dislike it you can turn off smart keeper mode in the settings.
Jalapeno 23 Aug, 2022 @ 3:33am 
it says: 20.1(Penny): false - SMART_KEEPER