great mod dude but i would like to suggest some things:
could you make the specific quest reward toggleable?
could you add a slider to make the minigame window bigger?

doesn't respect fishing in shimmer from other mods (Vitality mod was my issue)
it replaces the fishing minigame with default underground water

Does it works with multiple lures?

Hey, great mod

aight

You should add some visual feedback when you hit the timing on an item on the fishing bar. Maybe make the item jump and do a star-like background that rotates for a fraction of a second and then disappears

Same, I also can't find this mod by searching it on the steam workshop.

For some reason i can't find this mod through steam search, but it's my favorite fishing rework mod so far, great job!

@k4mikyo unfortunately, that's not an issue with just this mod, so I don't think they could fix it

please fix the ui problem, it disappears when talking to the angler

Fish probably shouldn't be able to start close to the left of the bar, I've already seen multiple times where a fish is so early on that if you don't have super fast reaction time it's impossible to get them. If this is intentional, then keep it i guess, but it's still pretty annoying.

the quest ui closing happens to me too, im not sure what the conflict might be but it just closes like a split second after speaking to the angler.

Sooo... It looks like you can catch Tuxedo Shirts in Lava. Probably due to Lava not containing any
catch in the category plentiful, except Crates.

Besides that your mod is great, removing many more annoying parts of fishing.

As for the Lava fishing Bug, you could either remove any catch that is 'Plentiful' and not a crate or add a filler, like a chunk of hellstone or a Lava version of the Neon Tetra

im playing solo and my menu started to disappear

Ive wanted to give a Update idea on the Bar and the (?) that appear, maybe make a indicator on what you have clicked on to make the ? glow up, and make them Thinner or make it to be a Line
as two or three ? can stack up on one single spot and its impossible to know if theres only one or more ? to be catched

I've noticed that too. It seems like it works if there aren't any other players alive when you try it, and sometimes if everyone else was in the underworld when I visited the Angler, it would work, but not consistently.

Ah ok. Yeah, I've been playing with a friend. Only sometimes it works and other times it doesn't. I wonder what causes it?

@Inarius Are you playing in multiplayer or using a mod that simulates other players? If so, that'd be why. It's not just an issue with this mod, though I'm not sure what's actually causing it.

Having a hard time getting the daily menu open. When clicking the "quest" button I see the menu but it then goes away. It doesn't stay open. Is this a bug or am I doing this wrong?

Any chance we could get an alternative recipe for the Lucky Sock that doesn't require an Old Shoe? It's in a weird, paradoxical sort of place where it's (usually) so useless it's rare, such that I've not actually managed to get one in several playthroughs. A recipe that uses Silk, or Hermes Boots, or something else, would be really nice.

I strongly recommend an indicator for whether a catch has been caught and will be pulled up. Maybe a visual effect behind the question mark/item.
Also sometimes the catches are so close to each other they are barely distinguishable. I recommend either a minimum amount of space between catches or for the green bar to catch all the catches in its range in one click, so that if two catches are in the green bar both will get caught.

@calvinosinclair Yes. "Without a high test fishing line there is a chance for each of these catches to not appear. If no catches appear, the line will snap when the minigame begins." I had the same question when I first started using the mod. It definitely looks strange, but it is an intended feature.

my line breaks 9/10 times. is this intended?

Also @WolfHero, the same issue has been happening to me for a while. I reported it in the dev's discord a couple weeks ago, so hopefully it'll be patched sometime soon?

@DiamondArmy hopefully this isn't too late, but I think the items you're talking about are Wet Bombs.

I don't know if this is happening to anyone else, but when fishing in lava using hell butterflies *and* the lavaproof fishing hook, I'm fishing up... tuxedo shirts? Not sure if Thorium's causing it but surely a weird bug.
Other than that, great mod!

Quick Question About The Bottom-Less water Bucket Quest Requirement It Shows An Unknown Water Container And I need 50 Of Them They Are Not Bottle Water? What Exactly Is That Container? Please And Thank You.

It seems like it works fine when I'm by myself, but the moment I have anyone join my server the questing window only opens for a frame and then goes away each time I click quest.

Not sure what's causing it.

Not better

Fishing in lava with lava critters is too difficult, the line very often insta-snaps even at respectable fishing powers.

It would be nice if hovering over the needed item for the daily quest shows the name of the item. I have a problem figuring out what a need to get the Super Absorbant Sponge.

Huh, ok. My mod browser has been giving me trouble over the past few days, I'll make sure it's up to date. Thank you!

Are you sure you have the latest update? ive tested it with fargos and the latest update specifically should fix blood moon enemies, as they werent working before that.

Yeah no, bobber doesn't do anything I'm not precisely sure which mods are conflicting, but fargo's and this mod seem to not like eachother rn.

gonna test if I still can with the fishing bobber as that seems to override fargo's changes

Hi, there appears to be a bug with the latest update. I cannot catch blood moon fishing minibosses (I'm pre-boss)

May be conflciting w/ Fargo's or something.

I cant replicate the issue in my game. I made some changes to the saving and loading of player data, so hopefully that fixes it

its just says that the quest is already in progress but i cant see wich fish i need

I've found the blood moon enemies issue, but im not sure where youre getting an issue with multiple lures. I don't plan on making this mod work flawlessly with multiple lures but for me at least it works and is useable, the line shouldnt be snapping instantly no matter what (if i read that comment correctly?) are you sure the catches arent just failing by chance because you dont have a high test fishing line? And about the angler reminder, as long as you have a quest active the text box should be updating with a quest. Is it saying a quest is in progress when the angler isnt asking for a fish in the text box?

I can't catch enemies during blood moons either

man can you add something that reminds you what you got to fish? cause i got the quest yesterday but i forgot what fish i needed to fish, and now everytime i talk with the angler he say that i have to work harder if i want something specific, but i really dont know what to fish!

golden carps? damn i did not know golden carps existed in terraria.

Could you work on this mod supporting multiple lures (but not all of them catching something)? When I fish with like, six lures, if only one catches something, then the minigame appears for what looks like a single tick and immediately disappears and I get nothing.

How does this work with fishing up enemies during Blood Moons? Didn't seem to work no matter how much I tried.

Any chance you can add a config that lets us choose how many catches each 10 fishing power gives?

Are you sure thats not 3 golden carps? I dont remember making anything take ichorfish

I like it. its very similar to Stardew Valley's fishing, which I'm already very used to and love. Thanks for this!

mate theres an issue with ur new sistem, the angler asked for 3 ichor fish, even though im in a pre hardmode corruption world

sweet, now I can start a new run with this mod without worrying about crashing, then again, maybe some other mod will have a conflict lol

i foung a bug where you can get 2 angler quest fish in the same throw with this mod