It seems the shieldwall ability itself decreases base weapon damage more than it used to, however in my testing it is still slightly more lethal than free melee. The ability also scales better and destroys cavalry much easier than free melee. There's still a tradeoff. I could tweak the shieldwall ability itself but it would then ruin the balance of other things.

yeah i am sure is not disciplined formation.May be you can test it and make some tweaks?

Shieldwall should work like a hoplite phalanx. Are you sure it isn't disciplined formation?

when activate shield war, it lower the damage so much but only increase the defense a little

dont know why you said that the shield wall make romans op,I test it in custom battle ,same units , non-shield wall beat the shield wall

@Summary No, I only got the quick and dirty summary.

@Chrissant

The three musketeers, I like that. But do you know there was a fourth :)

It only took 10 minutes for me, thank the three musketeers who made the original mod.

thankyou sir for making this