Some ideas for a few classes, the first two were inspired from some of the posts, but hopefully different enough. If not, I apologize.

Demoman

Secondary

The Classy Carpet Bomber

Upholstery courtesy of Tavish DeGroot

+50% faster fire rate
+Instant charge time
+50% increase in push force
+8 stickybombs out
-50% damage penalty
-50% more self damage

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=97494373&searchtext=

Pyro

Secondary

The Chilled Combustor

Why we never tell Pyro to chill out.

+On hit on burning enemy: Makes the player wet for 10 seconds
+On hit on burning enemy: Slows player (Equivalent to taking a bullet from Natascha.)
+Minicrits burning players
+Hitting a burning ally will extinguish them
-Extinguishes enemies on hit
-35% damage penalty

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=111102012&searchtext=

Scout

Primary

The Zap Cannon

Plug and play, and you just got PWNED!

+50% damage to buildings
+Critical hits stun players for one second
+Combo system: The third successful hit is a guaranteed crit.
+/-Can damage sappers, both friendly and enemy, with a flat damage equal to a hit from the Jag.
+/-Critical hits automatically remove sappers.
-25% Damage penalty
-Cannot be crit boosted besides the combo method

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=694916564&searchtext=

Any suggestions?

Something to think about that I remember someone posting about. The Brawn Over Brains PDA and Metal Shield PDA should have some sort of cosmetic to go with them to signify that the person has them equipped. Perhaps that's something to think about?

Some stuff for the Texan building man.

Wrench

The Neo-Tokyo Ninjaneer

I got the plans for this marvel of old-school engineering from some old merchant in koth_king.

+Sentries mark players for death. Higher level sentries mark targets for longer. (LV.1: 2 sec. LV.2: 3 sec. LV.3: 5 sec.)
+Pressing Reload will allow you to teleport between spawn and your exit teleporter
+Sentry rockets deal 5 seconds of bleed damage.
+Halves all upgrade costs
-All sentry attacks deal only one damage. (Does not affect bleed.)
-200% slower sentry fire speed

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=267151533&searchtext=

If we can give this the Wrap Assassin's hitsound, that would be awesome.

Primary

The Belligerent Bullpup

You better not touch his metal boy.

+Sentry damage charges a Rage meter. (Takes 400 damage) One full, pressing ALT-FIRE with this weapon will give you minicrits for 10 seconds, and 50% faster fire rate on your melee.
+Sentry kills, but not assists, will give you 25 metal.
-Using rage costs 50 metal
-33% smaller clip size
-15% damage penalty

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=390490889&searchtext=

Widowmaker firing sounds.

Wrench

The Welder's Wrench

Welding it together is better than bolting it together, but it takes a bit longer to get the job done right.

+Buildings get a 25% damage resistance shield while being repaired or upgraded.
+If a building takes no damage while being upgraded, it gains an extra 25 health. This can stack. Bonus goes away if it needs to be reconstructed, but can be regained in similar fashion.
+On hit: Ignites foe for one second.
-20% slower upgrade rate.
-20% slower repair rate.
-15% damage penalty.

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=76084965&searchtext=

Any suggestions?

Originally posted by QuandoVoceJogarTF2EuEstareiLá:

Originally posted by Kafhet Thrynity:

ghost charge isn't overpowered mate
it's quite easy to play against due to the charge trail

okay but the problem is the user can easily pass a sentry using charge

Keep in mind that you have no damage resistances. It's like complaining that the Eternal Youth Maiden or whatever it is now is OP because you can ignore damage some of the time, or that the Defense Push was OP because you had 75% resist all while charging. The Ghost Charge has that one benefit, but instead of that, you could be using the Tide Turner, Splendid Screen, or the Hybrid Knight shield of choice for tanking damage, the Chargin Targe. Including your nerfs will make the weapon unviable, especially considering that the people who use it tend to use it more for the extra charge second because they miss the pre-nerf Claidheim Mor.

Originally posted by Crafting | cTF2w:

Originally posted by A Spy!:

Well. I'll take a crack at something I think needs some work.

The Boston Bulldog.

Permanent overheal on a Scout while giving him a lot of health doing his bread and butter seems a bit much. What the idea seems to be is a Scout version of the Conniver's Kunai. Why don't we give it the same overheal decay as the Kunai when you Backstab?

+25% life leech that can overheal, with a cap of 200% max overheal
+Overheal decays 50% slower
-Cannot be overhealed by a medic
-20% HP penalty

The main reason reason it's "No overheal decay", becuase it would require a custom attribute and the coder couldn't 100% figure it out. I find a way to make the overheal decay to even effect overheal.

The problem the coder was having was that ANY overheal (which includes from a medic) was being slowed down, and not just from the life leech mechanic. So you can see what the problem is.

Also, the Boston Bulldog is acutally weaker to what it use to be.

Huh... That kind of sucks... The one thing I hate about that weapon is that you could get 200HP scouts running around with WAY more health than they deserve, and it was a death sentence if you got in a one on one match. That being said, I haven't been on too recently because I've been helping a friend with his server, so the whole thing with Demoman having invulnerability glitches (RIP Ghost Charge.) completely missed me.

I know I proposed a new weapon that worked similarly, but did a base heal on kill instead of life leech. In lieu of this, I would make it 50HP on kill, no health penalty, but a penalty to all healing you receive, smaller clip size, and less bullets per shot. Don't know if you want to scrap the Bulldog in exchange for a new concept, but there's an idea for you if you're interested.

Well. I'll take a crack at something I think needs some work.

The Boston Bulldog.

Permanent overheal on a Scout while giving him a lot of health doing his bread and butter seems a bit much. What the idea seems to be is a Scout version of the Conniver's Kunai. Why don't we give it the same overheal decay as the Kunai when you Backstab?

+25% life leech that can overheal, with a cap of 200% max overheal
+Overheal decays 50% slower
-Cannot be overhealed by a medic
-20% HP penalty

Originally posted by Crafting | cTF2w:

Originally posted by A Spy!:

Yeah, I'd like to put in my two cents, but it would be nice to know what needs the most work.

There's no list. It's just you sugguestions on weapons that might needs changes.

I suppose we're asking for anything the community thinks are really bad so we have an idea of where to start. This isn't like new weapon ideas, and I don't want to start naming things out of the blue if they're already fine. God forbid I pull a Valve and try to rebalance already balanced weapons if you know what I mean.

Originally posted by AwesomeGuyDj:

Can we get a list of all the weapons that need to be rebalanced?

Yeah, I'd like to put in my two cents, but it would be nice to know what needs the most work.

Originally posted by Kafhet Thrynity:

Originally posted by Loreknight:

Maxine buff
New stats
No movement penalty while spun up
Take ##% more damage while actice
##% less accurate

Here come back the old maxime

Perhaps we can throw in something like the heat meter for the Heavy Artillery Minigun. The longer you have Maxine spun up, the more vulnerability and less damage you do.

Some stuff for a few classes.

Pyro

Primary

The Chaff Blaster

Does a hell of a lot more than burn people, that's for sure.

+Flames also inflict bleed damage. Afterburn does not re-trigger bleed.
+Airblasts shatter stickybombs
+Airblasts also inflict bleed damage
-150% airblast cost
-50% direct flame damage penalty
-Rockets and grenades explode when airblasted.

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=229524401&searchtext=

Scout

Primary

The Trickster Tagger

Spray up your piece and escape.

+Dealing damage charges a Mural meter. (200 damage)
+Pressing ALT-FIRE when your mural meter is full will cast an invisibility spell that lasts five seconds and leaves a lingering team colored smoke cloud where you activated it.
-25% damage vulnerability while Mural is active.
-66% clip size
-20% less bullets per shot

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=103752492&searchtext=

Spy

Knife

The Attention Grabber

Make a big statement, with just enough time to pull off some Schadenfreude.

+On Backstab: Gain Dead Ringer activation buffs for 2 seconds
+On Backstab: Boost damage of your primary by 50% for five seconds
+Backstabs stun opponents for 3 seconds before dealing damage.
-On Backstab: Disable knife for 4 seconds
-Backstab damage is capped at 300 damage.
-Deals minimal damage on non-backstabs.

Model: https://steamhost.cn/steamcommunity_com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=148535301&searchtext=